Thanks for all the advice and support. I emailed him yesterday and told him I decided to keep the gun, which is true. I don't have the funds right now to purchase the gun I wanted, so for now, this pistol will reamin in the bed side safe.
Something just did not feel right about this deal. That's the best I can say it. So, as Coz_45 said, I'll be the responsible gun owner and not sell to him.
It's possible that someone on this board pointed him to the ad, in that case I may hear from them at a later date. If I do hear from a "regular" ARFcommer I may reconsider depending on who it is.
As far as the -1 on the EE rating I'm not worried. This is the first time to sell something on the EE and the -1 won't keep me from being able to buy (which I've done way too much
) and probably won't hurt me if I decide to sell something later.