I put a WTB: ad on a famous NFA trading board in mid 2004. I was answered with a S&W 76 that matched my specifications at a fair price. The gun was being brokered by a LV,NV shop for a local resident, and it was already being transferred to the store at that time. After taking approximately three months to actually get me photos of the gun, I mailed a check for the full amount (less $200 for the transfer).
It took another month or two for the dealer to get me forms. First set lost in the mail, excuses etc. Then, once I got them, the dealer recommended that after filling them out, I send them to him. He would submit them to the ATF, because he has a 'guy' that assists with processing the transfers faster, especially to C&Rs like myself. I was told that this would save me about a month.
So, on 2/11 I sent the forms back to the dealer, he received them, and held them probably for a bit less than a week before forwarding them on. Or so they have claimed. To date, my $200 transfer fee has not cleared.
I have been pounding the phone since September looking for a status, and out of frustration, called the ATF directly today. Using the serial number of the gun, they were able to track it's current owner, confirm that they have a match with the information I have, but NOTHING is in processes against the gun AT ALL. Basically, the dealer claims the paperwork has been with the ATF (through 'his guy') for nearly 11 months, and the ATF says it doesn't exist. So I'm probably 5 months out from getting my transfer approved.
I can't imagine that any shop carrying a Class III would dare execute a scam like this, because the ATF will come down on them so hard in conjunction with a postal fraud claim in place that it couldn't possible be worth it to do this for any amount of money. So I believe the gun exists, and frankly, at the price I paid and with 12 factory S&W magazines, I'd rather have it than have my money back.
But I feel helpless, like I have no leverage in the matter. I have no ATF forms to re-send for the transfer, and I have no access to the seller. I can't find a white pages listing on the seller (although I confirmed his name with the ATF, they checked by the serial number). With a dealer having my money that doesn't own the gun, do I really have any leverage at all?
I'm looking at a 24 months minimum from the time I agreed to the deal, 21 months from payment. What a disaster.
Thanks for listening.
-Dan