Quoted:
Quoted:
The G41 never took off as a design (and why we never had a semi-auto version here in the states) because it cost almost $2000 per unit to LE and gov't. A semi-auto version would have been about $2400 at a time when an HK91, 93 or 94 cost about $700. They would not have sold at all.
|
G41 never took off not becuase of how much IT cost, but becuase of how much a G36 cost in comparison. G41 was a quick 33 redesign after fall of the wall cancelled the G11 program. G41 was produced and proposed. PRobably would've been the finest battle rifle out there, and WELL worth the cost. BUT in comparison to G36 cost and export potential (which they actually underestimated!) this was not a tough choice. I think it came down to export sales more than anything else. While Germany may have been willing to buy the G41, I doubt any other country would have. G36 has MORE than covered for the G11 financial failure though.
In terms of us, I don't think we were part of hte equation! In the 80's HK cared about us, but 90's.... halfhearted efforts. And now......
|
The G41 was HK's attempt to compete with the M-16 within NATO entire. It used the M-16 mags as part of that competition, make it more attractive because the mags are cheap, plentiful and not proprietary in design. Supplying it to the Bundeswehr was part of that larger marketing strategy. The Bundeswehr was not THE market strategy. The M-16's cost was about $400-$700 per unit depending on quantity ordered. HK's proposed price was just shy of $1800. The G41 was an improvement in some respects, but not attractive at almost 4 times the cost of the M-16. When the Bundeswehr wanted the HK50 (what would become the G36), it was because of price, sure. But the G41 would have survived elsewhere, even without a Bundeswehr order, if the price wasn't so far out of the market. The G41's manufacturing cost and consequent market cost globally are what killed it. The G36 as a direct cost comparison might have been a factor for the Bundeswehr, but not NATO. There is still a resistence to the G36 within NATO and North American and European law enforcement because it is completely alien in design. Nothing interchanges with your neighbor or your sister agencies. Canadians, Americans, Britons, Swedes, Danes and others can all use each others' magazines. Spain and Germany and a random smattering of LE agencies are alone in the G36.
Besides, the Bundeswehr would never look outside of Germany for a new rifle. If the G41 were simply cheaper, it would have caught on. That's all.