I'm finishing up my first batch of 357 mag. Never loaded handgun loads before - only rifle. There are a couple things I'm wondering about.
First, I'm loading 158 gr JHP. Some are Hornady XTP and some Nosler. I'm using CFE Pistol powder.
I noticed when crimping that I was getting some very fine copper shavings off the bullets (see image below). It was a bit more obvious with the XTP but both did it. Any idea why? If it matters, my press is a single stage from the early 1980s and the ram sits at a slight rearward cant. I can sometimes feel a small catch on the downstroke. I'm wondering if the case might be tilting slightly and catching part of the die. If so, not sure what to do about that. The shaving are very thin and I can't even see where on the bullet they came from.
For brass I have some cheap Perfecta (which actually seems decent) and some Hornady from American Gunner rounds. For whatever reason the Hornady cases were about 0.04" inches shorter than the trim length as well as the Perfecta cases. In order to seat the XTP bullet at the cannelure I ended up with a O.A.L of 1.555" instead of 1.580" per the load data. Factory American Gunner ammo is actually only 1.545" (based on the ones I have and measured) so I'm assuming it's okay to be a bit short on O.A.L. Not sure why Hornady does this. Maybe make just a bit cases cheaper. They seat their bullets with very little cannelure showing. I went more towards the middle so they wouldn't be quite as short. Any issues with any of this? They chamber fine (I have a Ruger Blackhawk).
I double and triple check my loads, but the CFE only fills about 1/4 of the case and a double charge isn't that obvious. I did one on purpose to compare. I'm just wondering what would happen with a double charged load in a Ruger revolver (aside from scaring the shit out of me). I've heard stories they are no worse for the wear but wondering if that's more internet lore. Obviously something to be avoided.