Quoted: I'd venture to say a 1911 won't KB because even if it's out of battery, the cartridge is still fully supported by the chamber and breechface. If the slide were further out, the hammer couldn't contact the firing pin at all.
I'm looking at my SA1911 right now (with a snap cap in it). On mine, the hammer won't drop until it's FULLY in battery. Yep, trigger won't release the hammer until it's fully in battery. SO, the only KB I could see happening would be from an overpowered load. But heck, even with a .45ACP, you probably can't put enough powder in it to do more than throw some flame!
|
And you have just stated the entire problem. Autos with hammers will not be able to fire unless it's slide is completely closed and locked up. I'd be interested to know problems with other hammerless automatics. I'm not saying reloads aren't at fault in at least some of these scenarios, but if I took an automatic with a hammer, and fired it while the slide was not completely forward(with a real hammer and a punch), it would most likely kaboom, even with factory ammo.
I don't have a problem with Glocks concept, or manufacturing and quality. Personally I don't like the triggers, but what I complain most about is that they don't correct design flaws. They just keep making the same models without updating them. They should make the gun have the ability to be broken down without pulling the trigger(have heard a few cases of AD's because of this). They should make the gun unable to fire unless the slide is completely forward(taken care of by default on most hammered gun, so it understandable they did not anticipate for this problem to occur).
We aren't talking about major changes here, externally the gun would look the same, and only a few internal parts would need to be added/changed/removed.
I know Beretta fixed problems with their pistols(slidestop), Sig fixed theirs(reinforced frames), and 1911's have had many slight changes by the different manufacturers over time. It's time Glock made a couple small changes to their design, and these two problems would be eliminated.