There was alot of "gargage" associated with the SCAR trials. As great as the M16 is, it isn't going to be around to much longer and many of the vendors knew that the M16s replacement would likely be the winner of the SCAR contract. Since a pre-sol was already announced for a new Carbine and LMG, I think the wheels are already turning to replace the M16. While I have been involved in weapons testing, I can testify that sometimes the best weapon isn't the winner, its much more complicated than that. Politics, budget and personal connections/career ambition all play a factor. I am not challenging FN's victory as I have experience with thier SCAR canidate and its an amazing weapon which certainly earned a victory. Even though its an excellent weapon, being made by FN USA didn't hurt, as they are very well connected and polictically powerful. I am pretty sure FN could win contracts with a Daisy Red Rider....that being said, alot of time/money was spent on developing SCAR canidates and when the results were announced and FN's entry
was selected, millions of dollars were lost and people weren't happy. Rumours of impropriaties and corruption and court cases followed, but FN is hanging tough. The FN is already in the field, unfair practices or otherwise, the FN entry was an excellent weapon and it deserved to win, for the most part. Alex Robinson had some reasonable objections....he is a spook, IMO but I think all weapons should be fully evaluated and tested, provided they meet the requirements and he wasn't given a fair shake....and if you belive the rumors, nobody was. The pre-sol that was announced will be the real slug fest for the M16s replacement. All the usual suspects will show up, plus a few new comers. FN is going to have a leg up on all the entries because thier weapon will be the furthest developed. There is a big difference in the performance of a production weapon with combat experience and that of a prototype. The SCAR issue is settled, FN won and thier weapons are in the field killing terrorists. The only way the SCAR program would be re-done is if a lawsuit was successful and corruption claims were legally substantiated, then maybe.....as of now, its a done deal and everyone is gearing up for round two.