Seems like were always having the M1A .vs FAL .vs G3/HK91 debates,. I propose a new tangant.
Why not a lightweight boltgun? I know, I know the "Scout rifle" concept predates me by 20 years. But the Scout rifle isnt what i'm thinking.
IMHO a "Battlerifle" is a 18-22" barreled semi auto .308, magazine fed, and falling somewhere around the 10-11# mark.
Myself like a lot of other i'd guess began our "Black rifle" shooting on AR's. We've become acustom to a lightweight, shoudler fired rifle that we can make minute-o-man sized hits reasonably quickly out to distances where the naked eye cannot see "Minute-o-man" targets. Also like most other AR shooters we love that we can hit what we can see, We'd just love to hit it with a .308 instead. For most the natural choice is a M1A, others a FAL and still others a 91 variant. All three have strenghts and weaknesses in parts,reiablity and or ergonomics.
The 3 above choices will put you into the 1500$ range for a quality rifle+mags etc. Easily into the price range for a nice boltgun.
I propose a simple Remington 700 LTR in .308 with a 1.5-5 30mm Leupold. Nice and lightweight. The Remington can be made far more accurate in this application than needed, Has options/accessories out the wazzu, Including detactable box magazines of up to 20 rounds and is a beeze to maintain. No special reloading worries, will shoot damn near any weight bullet/powder combo and can be operated nearly as fast as a semi in a good shooters hands.
Just thinking out loud really, ..............udog