Quote History Quoted:
In just the last few/couple of weeks, I have been shopping for my first laser eye pro, thanks to the Perst 3 thread. And when looking at reviews on most of the ones Amazon sells there was a common theme. A lot of good reviews, then a 0 or 1 star review. Read that one, and it's a guy that tested it and they don't work.... seems there's a lot of "fake" or just China bob may or may not work... laser eye pro out there. A couple guys told me, don't by from Amazon buy from a "reputable source" so started looking at those, and wow $200 or more for a set of laser glasses, that may not even be rated as safety glasses (think shooting type safety glasses). So I ended up going the mil surplus way and got some NOS Revolution Sawflies. BUT those where only rated for specific Military lasers normally 1064nm. So I didn't know how they would do with my laser. Someone on hear also bought a set and tested them and shared. So I know they should work for me.
But to farther muddy the water. In my reading, some laser safety glass makers say that. A direct laser strike can change the chemical make up of the glasses, and that is part of how the glasses block the laser. And if the glasses have taken a direct hit, or have any discoloration. To discard the glasses. So I was just GREAT... how do I test them without destroying them... But I think my laser isn't enough power to worry about that, but I don't know. And someone was kind enough to already test what I am using so I feel good about it. BUT if he woudn't have done that. I would still be scratching my head and studying this topic. So I would love to learn some more about this topic.
View Quote
Just to make a note, some military goggles designed for range use specifically do not block 1064nm and would not have blocked the wavelength I was testing either. I have a list of which wavelengths they block, and I think it was primarily 808nm from memory, and a few others.
Others, which are used in the field, block a wide range of lasers, so it's important to check.
Here's some documentation on the more common laser-blocking filters supplied by the US military for field operations.
http://aunv.blackice.com.au/userfiles/david-Laser_filter_inserts_for_goggles_sun_wind_and_dust.pdf
This mentions some of the chemicals used to block lasers also.
I didn't know about the discoloration, but I think you'd be correct that a lower power laser wouldn't be able to do much. I don't think they are designed to deliberately burn through the blocking chemicals, which are usually soaked into the outer layer of the plastic, but I can imagine that if the heat was enough, it would certainly do so.
Some goggles reflect, much like the LIFs, by using dichroic mirrors that operate on the band to reject the desired wavelengths. Other use chemicals to absorb that band of the laser. Kind of like how a red filter won't ( shouldn't ) pass green light.
There's no reason that goggles should be expensive, and I suspect mine really are laser blocking goggles, but they are probably intended for another band... The problem is unscrupulous sellers who have no idea what their product does, so they lie about the capabilities of the goggles. Usually I test lasers under NODs, even if I use the daylight cover, and I guess I'll have to do the same once again. At least then I can see the beam and the spot clearly. I thought the seller I chose would have been better than I thought... I guessed wrong.
Lasers are like firearms. If treated correctly, they are pretty safe to use. But faulty safety equipment is still a problem.
Chinese safety equipment... *sigh*... I'm working on a validation project at the moment with respect to the stuff being sold in China, so I should have known better and tested my goggles long ago, rather than at the time when I needed to rely on them, and then I could have ordered some new ones and rejected these. Now I got to get some new goggles - :(
David.