Quoted:
I was thinking about the Marlin Papoose the other day. Neat concept, but I dont want to add a semi auto to my collection that isnt a 10/22. I want to stay with 10/22 for parts compatibility and because Im familiar with it. I believe the factory 10 round rotary mag that fits flush with the stock is superior to most all other .22 mags.
I disagree about the magazines. They're well made but they're not without fault. The concept is good but imo they don't work all that well with waxed lead bullets. They require regular disassembly and cleaning in order to consistently work properly. Mine will usually start causing FTF malfuntions somewhere between 50 and 100 rounds of waxed lead bullets. Ruger advises against disassembling the magazines on page 25 in the 10/22 owner's manual .
"Do not disassemble the magazine."
"Exploded view of the 10/22
magazine components. This
illustration is included to
show the relationship and
names of the magazine
components. As noted in
the text above, the
magazine should not be
disassembled."
They can, of course, be disassembled for cleaning, that's the easy part. The difficult part is the reassembly. Doing that and getting the proper rotor tension can be frustrating. The typical stamped sheet metal rimfire magazines are much easier to deal with. Strictly from a reliability standpoint, I think tubular magazines beat them all.