I am not sure what you are getting at eiether. I have hunted with my matching BPS 12/20 gauge highly finished field guns for years, and absolutely love 'em. The 20 gauge with rifle stock is probably the best upland gun I have ever shot. When I learned about the BPS Hicap, I bought one right away. I couldn't be more pleased...
As you know, the gun is bottom feed/eject like an Ithaca 37. The design is very similar to the former....There are two "forks" which recess into the top of the receiver which load and eject shells. There isn't a "paddle" type loader like on a Remington/Mossberg.
Reliability of the BPS is superior, certainly the equal of a M/R/W pump. The bottom feed eliminates an entry for debris but it also prevents you from rapidly feeding single shells into the chamber. Obviously, after shooting your gun dry, its faster to load single shells from the saddle into the chamber as opposed to loading the magazine, then chambering.
As far as I know, magazine extensions don't exist for the BPS. A 3.5 inch gun probably has a fair capacity for 2 3/4 inch shells. The magazine on my BPS hicap is one piece, unlike an 870. I have looked in the past, hoping to build a "defensive" BPS but wasn't successful. I think I paid 350.00 NIB for my Hicap. I absolutely love it, certainly the equal of any Remington/Mossberg/Winchester in terms of a defensive weapon. Accessories are unavailible, but I don't see this as a detrement. My 590A1/870 PM's/1300 Defenders are all tricked out to the max with Speed Feed this and Surefire that. My BPS hicap is SMOOTH, just a standard 8 shot 'guage, suitible for Rock n Roll.
I wouldn't mind a side saddle though....I'd reccomend buying a new or used BPS hicap as opposed to trying to build one.
Great guns...