when i started getting into 22s, the walther p22 was the first one i went to
however, further research led me away from this gun.
these were the things that bothered me.
1) "pot metal" slide. - never personally experienced, but have heard of them cracking. they say "zinc alloy blah blah" i see "pot metal". i prefer a stronger metal that will "last longer". esp with current materials technology, there is no reason not to.
2) finicky ammo - i buy a 22lr handgun to shoot dirt cheap. i want to be able to run federal bulk(3 cents a round) at minimum without experiencing fte ftf, etc. most report CCI mini mags run best (6cents a round) in the p22.
3) mag release - i prefer the mag drop button over the mag drop lever.
I used a p22 form a friend and they are a blast.. when they work.
edit: and they can work wonderfully with modifications. i just prefer a gun that can run 100% out of the box.
currently there are a lot of 22s with new ones as well.
they are also built with better materials as far as i know (no "pot metal" slides!)
check out the:
- ruger 22 pistols. they do look funny and are a pain to strip and clean, but they feed reliably with all sorts of ammo.
- newer ruger sr22 pistol, they seem promising and work with all sorts of ammo as well. reviews seem to be only positive.
- advantage arms 22 conversion kits. - i own one and it allows me to have trigger time on my g17. mine feeds fed bulk with no issues, but some people dont experience the same. but i personally love this kit the best. no lie, i put 500+ rounds through this kit with 4 friends (2 being new to shooting) and only experienced 1 fte.
- tactical sollution 22 conversion kits - i hear good things about these as well, similar to the AA kit above.
- S&W M&P22 - same makers of the p22 but the slide material is no longer pot metal iirc. it also now feeds all sorts of cheap ammo based of reviews. mags are expensive though.
im sure im missing some other models, but these are what comes to mind right now.