Quoted: Why change em out? Why fix what’s not broken? I have had my two Kimbers for over 7 years and they run great. I have not changed a thing on them other than the trigger and the mainspring housing. I think it’s weird how people will bash MIM parts on a 1911. Sig and other gun manufacturers use MIM and nobody complains about their parts.
|
Some people take the MIM thing to the extreme. Thee are two considerations with MIM parts in a 1911. The first thing you have to ask is "will I be staking my life on this gun?" If the answer is no, then it's truly a non issue. The second thing is, "if MIM parts are inferior, which parts are really affected?"
The second question is the one most people seem to miss. There are a lot of MIM parts in a Kimber or Springfield. Few of them are high stress. The slide stop and hammer are the parts that see the most stress and will for sure cause a stoppage if broken. MIM ambis have a tendency to break at the joint, and that could ruin a person's day. Other parts that are high stress but are much less prone to cause a stoppage are the firing pin stop and the ejector. Parts like the extractor, sear and disconnector rarely break, MIM or not. Other items, like the barrel bushing, the gripo safety, the mag release, etc. are non issues, though there might be an occasional freak breakage out there. This is also bound to happen with cast, forged and barstock parts.
My guess is people would complain about MIM parts in Sigs and other manufacturers if they were originally made with barstock and to cut costs they were currently made with MIM parts that have shown a history of pre-mature breakge. MIM technology is not really the problem though. It's poor execution by the vendors that supply Springfield and Kimber. I've learned a lot of information lately from my father in law who is a metalurgical engineer. His team at work designs military helicopter engines, and they use MIM for some very critical high stress parts. He knows all about metal stress, which is his specialty. I'm looking at MIM in a whole new light, and I'm conviced that wherever Kimber and Springfield get their MIM stufff, it's low quality.