Here is what I posted in another forum:
S&W 1911PD Scandium Review
I recently bought one of these for $750 new out the door. I was a little reluctant to buy it for a couple of reasons.
First, I have never owned a 1911 with an external extractor. I heard so many bad things about external extractors and the reliability problems associated with them, that I was somewhat concerned. However, I just put around two hundred rounds through it in one outing (150 Remington UMC ball and 50 Double Tap 1225fps Gold Dot). The pistol runs FLAWLESS. I used Wilson 47D mags, ACT mags, Kimber mags, and CMC powermags. Not one hiccup.
Another concern I had that with the lighter frame (about 10oz lighter), I might not be as accurate as I am with my other 1911s. I ended up being EXTREMELY ACCURATE with it, even with the Double Tap ammo. You feel the additional recoil with the Double Taps, but the bullet has already left the barrel at that point. Hell, the paper target doesn't even have time to tear around the holes.
To sum up the review, this gun is worth more than $750. It is a quality, reliable, and lightweight firearm at a modest price. It shoots as good as my Kimber Eclipse, STI Trojan, and amost as good as my Wilson Combat. And carrying around 28oz on your hip as opposed to 38oz makes a big difference in comfort.