Thanks for all the help, opinions, and advice.
I went back to the shop and was able to handle both the TRP and the DW Valor that was recommended above. To my inexperienced hands, they felt very very close in feel and appeared very similar in fit and finish to me. The trigger break and reset felt very similar, and I would have given an edge to the DW. They only had the DW in stainless though (I wanted the black) and the out-the-door price was at the high end of my range.
The TRP finish was the exact one I wanted, and the out-the-door price was further inside of my range, I've read nothing but good things about the TRP here (with the exception of a general dislike of the 2-piece guide rod) so I decided to go with the TRP.
I pick it up on Saturday
I liked the idea of going with something that was semi-custom over high-end production, but I figured that after enjoying the TRP for some time I discovered that the TRP had become one of my favorite pistols to shoot and I fell in love with the 1911 platform, then maybe I'd look to pick up a higher end custom in the future...maybe a Nighthawk, a Wilson, Les Baer, etc.
Thanks again for the help.