it's way too easy to get hung up on one Path to Enlightenment. Unfortunately, you are as likely to find Enlightenment in a drop of water as in the choice of a handgun.
There are though, certain guns that when they appeared, everything changed. These handguns were blazing milestones along the way. And most are still very competitive with all of the new ones that come along. That alone says that here is something new, something that is a primary condition. Each of these guns added something very significant that No handgun since then could Not include as a basic design feature.
I'm sure we can all put together a list of what we consider to be those most important handguns. Here is mine and I'll be interested in seeing what you folk consider the truly significant handguns.
I'm going to start with the Colt Single Action Army. There were others that were very similar, and even some that might have been better. But the Colt SAA simply changed the whole landscape. Here was a handgun that required only one component. No caps, powder, charges, ball. It was easy to load and reload. It was balanced and accurate and could be carried loaded for days or weeks on end.
My second choice was the S&W First Model American. Here was the first handgun that we'd recognize as being modern. It was a top break design and beloved by the Calvary. When you broke it open you could load all six chambers while riding a charging horse in the heat of battle. At that moment the SAA became as worthless as yesterdays newspaper.
When Smith & Wesson introduced the Hand Ejector, the first model with a swing out cylinder that all revolvers today use, there was another significant milestone. but unlike the effect of the advent of the First Model, the Hand ejector did not obsolete the Top Break models. S&W continued making top break models right up to WWII. Others such as Harrington & Richardson continued top break models right up to very recently.
The Colt 1911 was another milestone. It wasn't the first semi-automatic, they had been around for many decades, but it was the first that had been able to stand up to a rigorous Army testing. as with the Hand Ejector, the 1911 didn't mean that revolvers would go away, but it did legitimize semi-automatic pistols as something that must be taken seriously.
The advantage that a magazine offered for the average combat soldier was quickly recognized world wide, and just about every Military began a search for a semi-automatic for their soldiers. There were many really great attempts, notably the Luger. But none of those really worked when in the field. the Luger had so many moving parts and such a complex works that they couldn't be counted of except on parade and at matches.
But two others did work in the field. The P-35, another Browning design was the first successful hicap semi-automatic to come along. It met all the requirement of a field weapon, was reliable, cheap to mass-produce and held twice as many rounds as the 1911. Even with all of that capacity it was still a slim and light pistol.
The other real milestone was the Walther P-38. Here was a rugged semi-automatic that could be carried hammer down and fired double action first shot just like a revolver. In addition, it was just plain beautiful.
So those are my choices for the most significant handguns of the modern era. The Colt SAA, S&W First Model American, S&W Hand Ejector, Colt 1911, FN P-35 HiPower and the Walther P-38.
What would you list as the most significant handguns?