.....ok, back 2 the scenario: the mugger makes his move on John Q Citizen and sure enough, John Q whips out his Gat. As soon as he does, I shout "freeze, police (while showing a badge)...put the gun down!!" At this point, the mugger dissapears to the back of the subway car and John Q slowly lowers his gun and places it on the ground. Now, the instructor stops the scenario. He tells me that I should tell the person to DROP the gun and if they do anything other than DROP the gun, I am to shoot him. To illustrate this, he had me point my gun towards the reactive targets in the room. He then stood about three feet away from me with a pistol. He turned his body 90 degrees away from the targets. He said that as soon as I see him move (he was going to turn towards the targets and fire), I am to fire at the targets. Remember, I am facing the targets, he is turned 90 degrees to the right of them (and must turn 90 degrees to fire). Well, he started to turn and I fired. Guess what folks, he shot almost exactly at the same time as I did. This is due to the mental action/reaction process of the brain. Anyway, he said that almost universally, if your lucky, you'll get off a shot at the same time as the bad guy. So...he did all this to explain that cops are trained so that if they instruct someone to DROP the gun and the person starts to PUT the gun down, the cop should shoot. The instructor tells me that next time, if I say DROP the gun and the person starts to lower the gun, open fire.
So, we run the scenario again, this time another student (who is in an isolation room while others run the scenario.....and therefore oblivious to the reaction time demonstration and so forth) plays John Q. The scenario goes down exactly as before, however, I YELL at John Q to DROP THE GUN!!! John Q looks at me and I yell it again with emphasis on the word DROP. At this point John Q starts lowering the pistol and I shoot him about six times (At a range of about 5 feet with Simunitions cartridges). John Q. has this look of shock, bewilderment, and pain...(That BASTARD, He SHOT ME!!!, Why did he shoot me!!, Oh S*!T this hurts!!) At this point the instructor steps in and informs the student that I was under instructions to shoot him if he did not comply with my orders. The student said he put the gun down; the instructor asked him to repeat what I had yelled at him, the student said he was told to drop the gun, but did not think to actually drop the weapon. The instructor said that if you own a firearm, take it somewhere and drop it on the ground and get over the angst of dropping your beloved firearms on the ground. He said most folks cringe at the though of dropping their pistol or whatever on the ground, therefore they have a mindset that interferes with the concept of actually dropping a gun onto the ground. He then picked up the pistol (it was one of Sig's Simunition barreled pistols) and started to drop it on the concrete a couple of times to make a point......
The lesson learned from this:
If a cop says DROP the gun, you had better DROP the gun.