As far as match barrels go, it's not just the barrel, of which there are many manufacturers that make good ones. More importantly, it's how they are fit. If you get a "match" grade barrel that is drop in, chances are it won't shoot any better than the Springfield 2 piece barrel found in most Springers. A true match fit barrel is one that starts off oversized in several areas and will not even go in to the slide, let alone the gun, without fitting. The gunsmith fits several key areas to reduce the slop involved with a drop in barrel. Fit is where almost all the accuracy comes from.
The average 1911 without a match fit barrel is probably in the neighborhood of a 3" gun @ 25 yards for 6 shots rested. Some are significantly better, some worse. The average 1911 with a match fit, match grade barrel, is probably about a 1.5" gun on average when fit properly. What does this mean in a self defense scenario? Not much. It means something to a competitive shooter, but not much to an decent shooter who looks at the gun as a tool. This level of accuracy will cost around $300 - $400 on average between the cost of the barrel and the gunsmithing.
In answer to your question about who makes a good barrel, Bar-Sto, Kart, Nowlin, Clark, Jarvis, KKM, Schuemann, Ed Brown, Wilson Combat, Storm Lake, Briley, and Les Baer all make good barrels. Out of the above names, some are not actually made by that company (for instance, Nowlin and Kart make barrels for others). Most gunwriters prefer Bar-Sto, most smiths are split between Bar-Sto and Kart. You cannot go wrong with ANY of these, so pick the barrel based on price, or material if you want/need stainless.