Quoted: konger:
Ballistic gelatin is a valid test medium, and you shouldn't dismiss it. Comparison to real-life shootings shows ballistic gelatin to be an excellent match. Your application, however, is very specific, and as such the criteria you put out may very well be more important. I personally do not have any experience with large game animals and handgun bullet performance when heavy fur/hide/etc. are involved.
While bumping up the velocity on your bullet will probably buy you extra penetration, I would still be hesitant to rely on a J frame Smith as a reliable stopper for toothy critters. Obviously it's better than a pointy stick. Finding factory ammo is going to be pretty tough; if Buffalo Bore doesn't make something, your best bet is to handload. |
Oh, I believe that test gel is great for testing bullets made for self defense against humans, but I think there are just to many variables in the animal kingdom for gel to replicate. If you think about how fragile humans are and the shallow penetration depth needed to be effective, most any quick expanding bullet will be at least moderately effective. It's a wonder the ammo companies make the great products that we enjoy currently. I guess there's something to be said for specialization.
I have just today located a FMJ bullet in the S&B line (158 @ 850 fps), so that may be promising.
As for all of the suggestions to handload...I wish I could. Unfortunately, I went through an unexpected divorce last year and along with my house, I sold my reloading equipment. I'll get back into it someday, but for now, I need commercial ammo.
Thanks for the recommendation on the light weight .357. I choose the .38 because I didn't see me firing a ton of .357 Mags through the scandium framed gun. In fact, I heard it was down right painful to do so. So instead of blowing an extra $250 on a gun that was only marginally better, I settled on the 442 .38+P. I figure a light weight Mountain Gun is in my future, but even it may be a bit too large for stream fishing (sheeple). We all make compromises in our firearms. If I
knew for sure I was going to have a confrontation with something toothy, I would much rather have my 12 ga. shotgun in hand stoked with 3" Brennekes. Unfortunately, we can't always have the most effective gun at hand and must weigh the odds accordingly.