Are you that lame that you have to fall back on an age descrepancy?
Have you read Duncan MacPherson's book? How about Urey Patrick? You are still stuck on previously debunked myths started by Marshall and Sanow. Bet you are also a Massad Ayoob fan too.
On the contrary, you do want penetration, lots of it. "Lack of penetration gets good guys killed", who said, I dunno, but its a fact. Not to mention, that a nice midweight to heavy weight bullets, that are properly constructed , wont go tearing through people. Over penetration is over blown.
Reason why people think .357mag is so good, is because the round was in a revolver(limited ammo capacity stresses accuracy, and it was in a revolver, and for most, it screems power), and it was loud, and fast. In real testing, it crushed the same , amount of tissue, but doesnt penetrate all that deep. Its dumping everything so fast, that its stopping before it gets to the good stuff. The reason so many people died from it was also medical care, up until just a few years ago, it would be 30 minutes+ to get to a hospital.
Also, where in my posts did I say shot placement has nothing to do with shootings? I cant find it, and neither can you.
Where dd I say I believe in magic bullets? Your so damned stubborn, you probably didnt even click on the link. Those are real scientists findings, but you decided it was what you want to see, because it contradicts alot of your beliefs. See no evil, huh?