My first Sig (a P226) I bought at a gunshow rattled worse than an Army .45. I mean it was a police trade-in, was seriously worn in the finnish department, rattled like mad, it looked like hell, it just was plainly a high use gun. I was working for a FFL friend of mine at the time and he had it on his table for $375. Dozens of people looked at it because of the price. I mean it was a darn good price for a darn good gun, but it wasn't a cherry specimen to say the least. Several people came by several times, would play with it, go walking around to look at the $500 prices on the new/newer ones and come back, take it apart, etc. He was getting worried when no one would buy it by the end of the day at that price. I told him that I'd buy it at the end of the show if no one else did just to find out what the big deal was about Sigs.
Well, I wound up with it and as worn out as it was, it shot like a champ. I mean this worn out rattling gun drilled little small goups in targets better than most brand new guns (except other Sigs) and it would really hold it's own against a new one. That sold me on Sigs, and I proceeded to accumulate way too many of the things, and sold that one off to upgrade to a later model with the "mud rails" on the frame that was in much newer condition. Anyway, mine currently don't rattle, but when they start rattling, I'm not going to worry about it one bit.
Ross