User Panel
Posted: 5/22/2003 10:31:12 AM EDT
Below are the results of the 7.62 X 39 accuracy tests that RS39 and I performed over the last couple of months. All groups were shot at 50 yards to cut down on walking time in changing targets. Enjoy.
S&B MAK 90 - 4.5" Norinco Hunter - 5" SAR 1 - 3.25" SAR 1 - 2.75" Average = 3.875" Yugo 87 - MAK 90 - 3.375" Note that this round was also fired from an SAR 1 but the rifle really did not like the ammo and grouped over 8 inches. 95 Bosnian Norinco Hunter - 3.125" SAR 1 - 2" SAR 1 - 2.75" Average = 2.625" 77 Yugo. SAR 1 - 2.25" SAR 1 - 3.125" Norinco hunter - 2" MAK 90 - 2.75" Average = 2.53" Norinco Steel core MAK 90 - 4" SAR 1 - 2" SAR 1 - 3.625" Average = 3.208" East German MAK 90 - 4.5" SAR 1 - 1.75" SAR 1 - 2.437" Norinco Hunter 2" Average = 2.672" Wolf FMJ MAK 90* - 7.875" SAR 1 - 2.5" SAR 1* - 5" SAR 1 - 7.25" Average = 5.656" * Note, the MAK 90 turned in a 3" group if reduced to 4 shots with a flyer, and the noted SAR 1 shot a 2.75" group if only four shots were counted. This supports our testing that the Wolf FMJ appears to shoot poorly and inconsistanly. WOLF HP MAK 90 - 7.25" SAR 1 - 2.75" SAR 1 - 2.5" Norinco hunter - 3.875" Average = 4.09" Note, the MAK 90 shot a 4.125" group if only 4 shots were counted, and the first SAR 1 shot a 1.875" group if only 4 shots were counted. Although better than the FMJ, the Wolf brand showed more in inconsistancies than other brands. WOLF 154gr SP Norinco Hunter - 6" MAK 90 - 3.125" SAR 1 - 2.875" SAR 1 - 2.5" Average = 3.625" Note the Norinco Hunter shot a 5" group if only four shots are counted. Also of note, in one SAR, the group printed very high on the target, and the other SAR, the group printed very low on the target. groups were similar, but POI was about 8 inches different between the two rifles. This round seams to be the saving grace for Wolf ammo. Barnaul HP MAK 90 - 3.625" SAR 1 - 1.25" SAR 1 - 2" Norinco hunter - 2.375" Average = 2.31" Note, the first SAR 1 shot a .625" group if only 4 shots are counted. Barnaul FMJ MAK 90 - 2.125" SAR 1 - 1.25" SAR 1 - 1.75" SAR 1 - 2.25" Average = 1.84" I think we have a keeper here folks. Barnaul SP Norinco Hunter - 2.5" SAR 1 - 1.5" SAR 1 - 2" SAR 1 - 2.5" Average = 2.125" Note on this ammo. We also tested the Brown Bear ammo (also a 125 grain SP) that is made by Barnaul. I have lost the data in the shuffel here, but it shot about 25% larger groups. this made us think about what the BB line really is. It shot well, but not as well as the "same" ammo in the Barnaul box. We wonder if this is ammo that does not meet the quality standards to put into their own boxes or if it is something else. It could have just been a variation in lots as well, but was signifcant enough to note. Siver Bear match (Barnaul) MAK 90 - 1.125" SAR 1 - 2.312" SAR 1 - 2.875" SAR 1 - 2.125" Average = 2.11" Note that the first SAR 1 shot a four shot group of 1.75", and the second shot a four shot group of 1.625". While over all fine groups. A little more consistancy would have made this the best of all groups averaging under 2". Klimovsk MAK 90 - 4.75" SAR 1 - 2.875" SAR 1 - 4.25" SAR 1 - 2.5" Average = 3.59" Note that the MAK 90 shot a 4 shot group of 1.625", and the second SAR 1 shot a 4 shot group of 2". Again, flyers opened up the groups consistantly. Uly FMJ SAR 1 - 2.375" SAR 1 - 2.438" Average - 2.41" This type of ammo was not tested in the first round as I did not realize I had cases of it until the second round of testing. It did seam to very consistant ammo. Uly HP SAR 1 - 2.25" SAR 1 - 2.25" Average = 2.25" Only one round of testing for the same reasons as above. The second SAR put a four shot group into 1.125". Still a consistant brand of ammo. South African SAR 1 - 3" SAR 1 - 3" Average = 3" Lapua SAR 1 - 3.5" SAR 1 - 2.25" SAR 1 - 2" SAR 1 - 1.688" Average = 2.36" Note that the first SAR had a 4 shot group of 2.25", and the third one had a 4 shot group of 1". Very fine ammo, but no better than MUCH cheap Russian ammo for the AK. Federal American Eagle FMJ SAR 1 - 2.25" SAR 1 - 1.75" Average = 2" Remington SP SAR 1 - 3.625" SAR 1 - 3.875" Average = 3.75" Winchester Super X SP SAR 1 - 2.4375" SAR 1 - 1.375" Average = 1.91" (rounded) I am still in denial about this one. I refuse to belive that Crapchester shot this well. [Al Gore] I want a recount, or three or four [/Al Gore] Cheetah SAR 1 - 1.5" SAR 1 - 2.875" Average = 2.18" We were limited in our testing of this round by the amount on hand, but it appeared to be a promising round. Special thenks to Njogi for the donation of this ammo. This is it guys. It was hard work but someone had to do it. The first round of 5.45 accuracy testing is done, with the second round scheduled after Bulletfest. We hope this is helpfull to all of you. |
|
great reading!
accuracy tests at bulletfest???? yer kidding? right? heheheh! oh...after bulletfest! i'm surprised the hunter shot that poorly. |
|
Must waste all junk Wolf ammo while at Bulletfest.
Accuracy test afterwards yes. Unless someone would like to walk out and reset the targets for us every 1.1 seconds! The Hunter was a strange rifle. It had a 20 Inch barrel, but the way the trigger cam back so your finger could reach it reminded me of a medievil crossbow. I liked the peep sights, but they were way too large. The SAR rifles were ergonomicly much better IMO. |
|
The Romanians were kicking in Mao's penis! I bet Mao is currently killing all the employees at Norinco as I type. Perhaps barrel wear had something to do with it? Obe916, how many rounds were put through each gun before each test? Also, what was the cleaning routine before and after each test? Barnual wins hands down unless you want to pay out the ass for Winchester. I wonder if that round is made by IMI, like the Q3131A. Winchester doesn't make all their brass and bullets in Alton, IL any more due to capacity. |
|
Definitely not a good advertisement for Norinco products!
Interesting stats though, thanks for the report. |
|
Interesting, good info though. Supported or offhand? Any modifications to the rifles?
For stock guns that seems about par for the course in my experiences, my Red Star triggers have, however, given me that kind of accuracy at 100-150m from similar weapons, namely a MAK90 and a SAR1. |
|
Honestly I was surprised by the poor performance of WOLF. After all, it is made at Tula. They have been around a long time. Besides, all commie ammo is the same right??? Guess not.
The rifles were shot from a cheap rest from a table. The Norinco Hunter was stock as far as I know, and its performance, I think was due to its' modifications to the "Hunter" configureation. One SAR had and RSA trigger group in it, but has less than 10 rounds through it at the time of the testing. It did have a problem with an out of spec trigger pin hole causeing the trigger to become inconsistant with a different pull each time. I know it had an effect on the groups, and I had a lot of called flyers. The MAK 90 is used but with less than 2K rounds. The trigger is a mix of the best parts I took out of the SAR rifles. Not as nice as the origional trigger, but nice. I am not quite sure on the specs on RS39's SAR.As far as number of rounds fired, I have no idea, but the tests show about 2/3 of the targets. More background info later....... time to feed the brat. |
|
Personally knowing both Ober and RS39, all I gotta know is who has barnaul in stock. Bulletfest is coming and never let it be daid that I don't feed my rifles the best?
|
|
Themao, I don't know about RS39, but my cleaning consist of a toal complete take down and cleaning of every part I can take out after each shooting. Yes, I know its an AK, but it's how I was trained.
I was surprised at how picky the MAK 90 was with ammo. A few types I couldn't even keep on paper, other types shot realitivly well. My SAR was a little picky, but not having been broken in might have had a little to do with that. Shotar, I know that the Ammo store here in Canton should be getting in Barnaul HP very soon, and Dans Ammo www.dansammo.com has it in stock. $48 / 500 shipped. I would have liked to clean the rifles half way through the second round of tests, but we were out there long enough. RS39 probably would have shot me if I had spent 45 minutes cleaning my rifle. |
|
Something is not quite right with this one... The average is larger than any of the components. Great info. Thanks for the tests. I'm eagerly awaiting the 5.45 tests. Kent |
|
|
Great Work and Thanks for test work! Ob916 and RS39.
Ob916 .. Are you going to pin the data in the Ammunition Section ? |
|
Interesting that the Mak-90 shot both the best (1.125) and worst (7.875).
|
|
That is some awsome info.
Thanks for taking the time to give us this great data. I am sure it was hard duty, and you hated every minute of it! |
|
Fixed. Oops. Njogi, I will put this up in the ammo section once it has run its course here. Again thanks for the ammo. Despite my admited bias towards it. It did shoot very well. |
||
|
Over a few sessions we hopefully averaged out any key variations in our shooting skills. 50 yds helped not only with target set time, but kept this more of an ammo test and less of a vision test. The Norinco Hunter is not represented in all tests because the person who sold it to me last year asked for it back as part of a HKG3 clone deal. Playing with the screw tension for the full-size handguard over the gas tube and bbl below would have probably helped harmonics. We suspect that variation in headspace may be the cause of the SARs occasionally different behavior, but that measurement will have to wait.
There is a strong case for Russian ammo all coming with powder from the same plants, steel from the same plants, and staff from the same training schools. But the potential for variation in equipment setup and maintainence in real, so quality control may be the reason for the differences. And the Western ammo was a big surprise; too bad it is so much more expensive. I'd guess that my SAR1 has 8000 rnds thru it. I do not save my box tops. And cleaning the guns part-way thru does not represent real-world AK conditions. I may be German, but I am not that anal. That Austrian guy must have grown up too close to Switzerland, or his French border wife is training him to be difficult |
|
damn...a kraut and and austrian armed in ohio? and they didn't invade minerva?
I do not save my box top. i do. after you get 1000, you can send them in for a free t-54. i gotta get in on the 5.45 test. i think i have some rws to try. and no...you ain't shooting up my russian military ammo! |
|
I agree with RS39, I am more into real world tests than nice clean lab teast. It would have proved little to allow for full barrel cooling and a full cleaning between changing ammo types.
We didn't have to invade Minerva, all the French in town heard the shooting and came out to us and surrendered! Bob you are invited for the 5.45 testing, first round already shows interesting results. Don't worry, your Russian ammo is safe. RotDorn has already sent me some of his. I guess we know who the good staff member is around here. |
|
You already do the farming for us and let us hunt on your land, so why invade? Although we do fly black RC helicopters there to keep folks nervous
I should add that we were very consistent in rotating guns with every group shot for consistent bbl temps. |
|
Gentlemen: I'm impressed and offer my compliments. Time to burn lacquer.
Whats the difference between S. African and Cheetah? |
|
The South African is 1988 Dated Ammo that came is clear Battle Packs probably packed by Denel, yet Boxes are Trapozoid boxes like the 5.56 SA , yet have nothing labeled on the white Sticky. The Cheetah is 1997 Dated Ammo packed in Commercial Boxes of 40 rnds, in 1440 rnd Wooden Crates. The Cheetah is made in Zimbabwe by Zimbabwe Defence Industries, using Norinco Machinery. Cheetah groups better in my AR 7.62 Upper. On the AKs the results publish shows that too.
Both function good, both are Berdan Primed and both have sealed primers, Green on SA and Red on Zimb. Cheetah is still available and SA is rare find now. Seriously, I prefer these brass Ammo on AR because the primers are not as hard as on the Wolf, and hence the Russian Ammo requires 2nd Hit on my Ar.. |
|
Well done. You've done all he kind of stuff I think about doing but never get to it when at the range. 50 yards was a good choice.
That dang Wolf, my flyers flew farther, but such a lovely bullet for an AK, sleek, boat tailed and made to tumble. |
|
I'm not surprised. I once owned two Mak-90s and sold them due to lousy accuracy. My own experience agrees with yours w.r.t. the SAR-1 and by extension the WASR-10. I have a WASR-10 hi-cap that is the most accurate AK that I own, with consistent 1.5 MOA using Barnaul and Silver Bear Match. Nice work on the report, good info, and I appreciate your sharing the data. Noah |
|
|
Very informative...thank you for your time and effort to compile this.
It will be very useful in about 2 weeks time for me. Again, thanks, Y- |
|
Y- Glad you like it. We also started the 5.45, but with just one Bulgy 74 kit build. A very nice gun but not enough potential variation in bbl and headspacing to start publishing results. We'll get a few SAR2s at least added to round 2, and I'd like to toss a Krink in the mix for a SBR comparison.
|
|
|
No problem, it was tough work, but RS39 and I took one for the team.
|
|
You can get Barnaul 7.62 x 39 ammo at sportsmansguide.com. They only have the JHP and SP though. They have the best prices on ammo that I have found so far as while.
|
|
www.midwayusa
has it for 41.67 per 500rds plus shipping,all bullet types. |
|
I got 500-rds of Barnaul 123-grain for $47 off SOG...
That is some good ammo, and great ammo for the price. Shoots really well, nice groupings. |
|
Very informative -- Been getting Barnual at Dan's here locally and I saw that AIM has Uly at $69/1000 for the next few days, which is awesome compared to most who are charging about the same for 500 to 700 rounds depending.
A762x39Russ Russian 7.62x39 124grn Hollow Point New Production, Russian, Sapsan, 7.62x39 Ammunition! 124grn, Hollow Point, Steel case, and Non-Corrosive. 2,330fps. Packaged 20rds/box, 1,000rds/case. Sold as 1,000rd case only. SPECIAL INTRODUCTORY OFFER! Offer good thru 04/28/04 only. Normally $69.95ea while supplies last. Introductory Offer! 1,000rd case: $65.00 |
|
Just shot some of the Silver Bear 123gr "Match". I was zeroing a PK-AV on an SA85M. Shot a 3" group at 100 yds. Best group I've ever got out of a 7.62X39 AK. Only shot 100 rds, but I bought a case. Price was about $95.00/1000 from Ammunition Store including shipping from OH to MI.
Seems like good ammo. |
|
So, it looks like the 7.62 x 39 doesn't come close to being as accurate as the AR 15 in 5.56?
|
|
Really? It's hard to make a cartridge that has the trajectory of a rainbow shoot accurately past 300 yards. 7.62x39 wasn't made (obviously) to compete with the .223. It was made to put lead out there quickly and put joules on target. |
|
|
My 7.62x39 Colt AR15 upper gets 2moa on cheap Russian ammo, and 5.45/5.56 AKs get similar groups. |
|
|
Or wolf, but we already knew wolf was crap to begin with, thats why its so much fun to bumpfire, you dont plan on hitting anything with it anyways. |
|
|
Will have some comparison with Barnaul (blue box) and Magtech FMJ later this month
|
|
I haven't seen any magtech in this caliber. It has gone down hill pretty badly in qaulity in the past few years. I wouldn't expect much out of it.
|
|
Next round ask around for diferent brands of ammo that you dont have and i will contribute.
Robotizing, |
|
The Silver Bear Match that I have says that is was made in the Ulyanovsk Machine Tool Plant.
How would this stuff compare with the Silver Bear Match made by Barnaul? |
|
The Ulyanovsk made Match Silver Bear has the nipple on the end of the bullet, right? Barnaul doesn't make such a bullet nor do they plan to.
No comparison. Y- |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.