Well, thanks for all the input guys, but let me throw another loop at you. From the first post on this thread, I mentioned that the bolt had locked into battery. I had to disassembly the upper from the lower, and then use a brass drift to whack the rear of the bolt carrier to get it unlocked. When the bolt popped free, the case was not with it. We had to remove the case from the chamber as it was still in there after we removed the bolt. SO, my question now is, could the extractor tear on the rim be from when we forceably removed the bolt from the case during the whacking rearward of the carrier. I wonder if I had a case that didn't size correctly and was stuck thus locking up the bolt. When we whacked the bolt backward, with the case still stuck in the chamber, the extractor tearing off the rim would give the same effect yes?? I am just confused, becasue the upper was purchased used and broken in, 100 rounds or so. I figured it would just work. This is my first AR, so I am still learning. Thanks in advance for all your patience!
Dan