I have just built a 6.8SPC upper with a Vltor MUR-1 receiver. 16" Bison Armory 6.8SPC 1:11 OD Gun Kote barrel, Adams Arms .750 Lite Piston System and Sampsons Evolution 9-EX rail, and my Sampson rail works just fine for my set-up! The Samson EVO 9-EX went on my upper fairly easily after I realised that I had the barrel nut bushings on backwards (MY FAULT) and thanks to Scott at Sampson for pointing me out to the diagram in the Directions I should have been looking at in the first place! I thought since I put the EVO 12.37 on my other upper that I knew how to install the rail without having to look at the directions again.
I say those guys on the other forum either had some bad luck or they did the same thing I did which was not follow directions, and also if they did have problems with the EVO rail, Samsons Customer Service is excellent and would have resolved their problem if they would have just contacted them.
Also my rail installed very tight and is sturdy as can be. It does not move!