Quoted: I would say no also...My stock bushie barrel came loose in my upper after about 1500 rounds in a matter of about 1 1/2 years. I wasnt too impressed with that, but shit happens.
|
While not favorable - this can happen to any manufacturer. When you tighten the barrel nut, you snug it three times to the minimum torque. (or just get it hand tight) Then you review the gas tube alignment cuts in the barrel nut. The design is to tighten the barrel to the next available gas tube alignment cut, so it will line up with the hole in the upper receiver. Sometimes this takes minimal torque, sometimes it will take a lot. It all depends on the barrel nut/receiver threads.
If the correct alignment is reached, and the torque is not enough, you go to the next hole.... this almost always leads to overtorquing. For the home builder... big deal, torque away. For the manufacturer, they should try a different barrel nut until they reach a combination where they hit good alignment and stay in the spec torque range.
Occasionaly, the correct alignment is reached, and the torque is withing spec, but on the bottom range of the torque spec. These barrels have the highest likelyhood of shooting loose. When I say loose - it is not a danger issue - they will just slightly rock back and forth a tiny amount. The play is caused by the barrel nut no longer frezzing the barrel extension shoulder against the receiver, and the indexing pin on the extension can rock slightly inside the upper receiver indexing slot. You could shoot for years like this with no ill effects, other than the chance of a slight windage error when using irons. Bushmaster (or any manufacturer) would obviously correct this problem.
I have it happen much more often when using aluminum barrel nuts, like on free float installs. That is just another reason I prefer the LaRue rails, because they still use a steel barrel nut.