Quoted: Thanks for the responses.
In reading Pat Roger's article in the November 2005 SWAT magazine he says the TA31 is effective from contact (the end of the muzzle) to 600 meters while the TA11 is useful from 50m to 600 meters.
I don't understand why the TA11 with less magnification, 3.5x, would be a problem as some on this site have said they have experienced in that 0-50 meter range, where the TA31 with 4x magnification is OK. Is this just that some people can utilize the BAC and some can't?
|
Tim,
I own a couple of both (TA31 and TA11).....Inside of 50 yards both ACOGs are slow, due to the magnification. Both the TA11 and TA31 really shine at distances from 50 to 600 yards. Take any 3.5x or 4x optic you have laying around the house (ie. a 3-9x40 scope, etc) and try to quickly get on target at 5, 10, 15 yards. You will see that at these distances 3.5x or 4x is too much magnification and really narrows what you can see on the target. Often times all you will see is a cardboard colored blurr. But with a little practice you can quickly learn how to compensate to get hits on target at closer distances.
If a majority of your shooting is going to be 200 yards and in (with a lot of 50 yards and in shooting) you may be better served with an electronic red dot like the Aimpoint or EO Tech. If a majority of your shooting is going to be 50 yards and out, I would choose an ACOG.
I like the size of the TA31, but when shooting on the move, from odd positions, etc. the longer eye relief of the TA11 is a hands down winner. I know Trijicon says that the eye relief on the TA11 is 2.4", but I have found that it is much more generous than that. Trijicon states that the eye relief on the TA31 is 1.5" and I have found this to be true.
I am a "nose to charging handle" shooter and on carbines with collapsable stocks the TA31's work well for me. In a perfect world Trijicon would make an ACOG that had the eye relief of the TA11 in a optic the size of a TA31. You can't go wrong with either ACOG, it just depends on your personal preferences.