OK, I'll bite[:D] Now you'll read that the US GI are the best, because they're made by the best people, and they always work. Generally speaking, that's true. What you won't read is that 1)if you drop one on it's feed lips, on any hard surface, the lips will bend and the thing won't feed right any more, or that 2)the feed lips crack after awhile (yes, a long while).
What you also won't read is that the base plate retaining lips at the bottom will start breaking off after a few disassemblys. That is, unless you catch the posts from the guys who bought used GI mags from an unscrupulous vendor, and found the base plates wired on.
Now the Thermold detractors will tell you that they crack and break, and you can't leave them loaded because they swell up and get hard to insert. Well the six Thermolds that I've had loaded and unfired for over a year now must not have heard that piece of wisdom, because they're neither swollen nor cracked. The two Canadian jobs mentioned in my first post do swell slightly after awhile, but they haven't cracked either. If you have a Rock River or (some) Bushie lowers, you may have to thin out the overinsertion rib on the Thermold, to get it to lock in, and that's about the only downside of the things. Thermold dimensioned the things to go into Colt lowers, and Colt chamfers the bottom of their mag wells more than most of the aftermarket folks.
Certainly, milspec aluminum mags are good products. I've got a couple of the 20 rounders myself, for bench shooting. It's just that my personal experience with American Thermolds has been nothing but positive, so I'll stick with 'em until that changes.