User Panel
Posted: 8/19/2019 5:17:02 PM EDT
I bought some XM556FBIT3M from Target Sports USA that came in a .223 pressure loading. This is different from my 5.56 pressure TBBC that I have. Is there a significant difference in velocity or terminal performance between the 5.56 and .223 loadings? Is the .223 loaded FBIT3 as good as the 5.56 version?
|
|
I’m confused. If the part number is XM556FBIT3, then it should be loaded at 5.56 pressure. Were you told different?
|
|
Maybe the same exact bullet is used in a 223 hunting load since it's originally a hunting bullet (Bear Claw).
There is probably 100-200 FPS difference. But the 223 load is probably more accurate. But I'm guessing and will stand by for actual data. |
|
Quoted:
I'm confused. If the part number is XM556FBIT3, then it should be loaded at 5.56 pressure. Were you told different? View Quote https://www.bonefroggunclub.com/products/556-62gr-federal-tactical-bonded-xm556sbct3 https://www.targetsportsusa.com/federal-fbi-duty-556-ammo-62-grain-tactical-bonded-sp-xm556fbit3m-p-109726.aspx |
|
The batch I got (think the designation ends with an M and is .223) is pretty anemic. I'd have to check, but I want to say I was getting low to mid 2400s out of an 11.5" suppressed.
For comparison, the 64g Gold Dots I tested on the same day netted a solid 100fps more. |
|
It's .223 loading:
.223 Remington, 62gr Bonded, XM556FBIT3M, Velocity Test |
|
Quoted:
The batch I got (think the designation ends with an M and is .223) is pretty anemic. I'd have to check, but I want to say I was getting low to mid 2400s out of an 11.5" suppressed. For comparison, the 64g Gold Dots I tested on the same day netted a solid 100fps more. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Well that sucks, Guess I'll just have to order the 5.56 stuff from bone frog gun club and just shoot the .223 stuff as expensive range ammo. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Well that sucks, Guess I’ll just have to order the 5.56 stuff from bone frog gun club and just shoot the .223 stuff as expensive range ammo. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Looks like XM556FBIT3 is .223 and XM556SBCT3 is 5.56 pressure. https://www.bonefroggunclub.com/products/556-62gr-federal-tactical-bonded-xm556sbct3 https://www.targetsportsusa.com/federal-fbi-duty-556-ammo-62-grain-tactical-bonded-sp-xm556fbit3m-p-109726.aspx View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Interesting. I think the “M” denotes .223 pressure as the original FBI contract round was 5.56 pressure. The SBC round was a different solicitation and is intended for short barrel carbines. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Looks like XM556FBIT3 is .223 and XM556SBCT3 is 5.56 pressure. https://www.bonefroggunclub.com/products/556-62gr-federal-tactical-bonded-xm556sbct3 https://www.targetsportsusa.com/federal-fbi-duty-556-ammo-62-grain-tactical-bonded-sp-xm556fbit3m-p-109726.aspx From what I can tell, XM556FBIT3M is indeed a .223 pressure load since both the box and the case headstamp are marked .223 REM. The FBI seems to have started purchasing this instead of the original 5.56 pressure XM556FBIT3 as early as 2015 (maybe earlier) based on some contract awards I found. I'm not totally clear on the SBC designation. Bone Frog says XM556SBCT3 is the same thing as XM556FBIT3 with the SBC simply indicating that it is not FBI-contract ammo. However in a thread from last year, a reliable source said that the current FBI contract round was .223 pressure XM223SBCT3, which throws a bit of a wrench in things as far as product numbers. He did note that they switched to the .223 load because it was more accurate. Regarding usage in SBRs, testing in short barrels has been one of the requirements for the FBI contract for almost a decade. FBI's 2010 solicitation that led to the adoption of XM556FBIT3 mentions that the ammunition will be evaluated in weapons with barrels as short as 10". A 2015 RFP (which also confirms that XM556FBIT3M was the current duty round at that time) notes that ammunition will be evaluated in 11.5" barreled rifles, including a test for optimal penetration and expansion in ballistic gelatin at 100yds. That solicitation resulted in a $15 million contract award to Vista Outdoor (Federal's parent company), and smaller awards to Winchester (presumably for RA556B) and Hornady, so I'm confident that the .223 pressure T3 load performed well in their testing. FWIW, DHS/ICE have also selected a .223 pressure T3 load with yet another unique product number as an "enhanced" duty load with a 62 grain Gold Dot-based load as their "standard" duty load. |
|
Quoted:
Deciphering all the various product numbers for the various FBI/T3 loadings is a bit challenging without solid info from the manufacturer. I asked our resident Federal expert for some clarification in this thread but haven't received a reply. From what I can tell, XM556FBIT3M is indeed a .223 pressure load since both the box and the case headstamp are marked .223 REM. The FBI seems to have started purchasing this instead of the original 5.56 pressure XM556FBIT3 as early as 2015 (maybe earlier) based on some contract awards I found. I'm not totally clear on the SBC designation. Bone Frog says XM556SBCT3 is the same thing as XM556FBIT3 with the SBC simply indicating that it is not FBI-contract ammo. However in a thread from last year, a reliable source said that the current FBI contract round was .223 pressure XM223SBCT3, which throws a bit of a wrench in things as far as product numbers. He did note that they switched to the .223 load because it was more accurate. Regarding usage in SBRs, testing in short barrels has been one of the requirements for the FBI contract for almost a decade. FBI's 2010 solicitation that led to the adoption of XM556FBIT3 mentions that the ammunition will be evaluated in weapons with barrels as short as 10". A 2015 RFP (which also confirms that XM556FBIT3M was the current duty round at that time) notes that ammunition will be evaluated in 11.5" barreled rifles, including a test for optimal penetration and expansion in ballistic gelatin at 100yds. That solicitation resulted in a $15 million contract award to Vista Outdoor (Federal's parent company), and smaller awards to Winchester (presumably for RA556B) and Hornady, so I'm confident that the .223 pressure T3 load performed well in their testing. FWIW, DHS/ICE have also selected a .223 pressure T3 load with yet another unique product number as an "enhanced" duty load with a 62 grain Gold Dot-based load as their "standard" duty load. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Looks like XM556FBIT3 is .223 and XM556SBCT3 is 5.56 pressure. https://www.bonefroggunclub.com/products/556-62gr-federal-tactical-bonded-xm556sbct3 https://www.targetsportsusa.com/federal-fbi-duty-556-ammo-62-grain-tactical-bonded-sp-xm556fbit3m-p-109726.aspx From what I can tell, XM556FBIT3M is indeed a .223 pressure load since both the box and the case headstamp are marked .223 REM. The FBI seems to have started purchasing this instead of the original 5.56 pressure XM556FBIT3 as early as 2015 (maybe earlier) based on some contract awards I found. I'm not totally clear on the SBC designation. Bone Frog says XM556SBCT3 is the same thing as XM556FBIT3 with the SBC simply indicating that it is not FBI-contract ammo. However in a thread from last year, a reliable source said that the current FBI contract round was .223 pressure XM223SBCT3, which throws a bit of a wrench in things as far as product numbers. He did note that they switched to the .223 load because it was more accurate. Regarding usage in SBRs, testing in short barrels has been one of the requirements for the FBI contract for almost a decade. FBI's 2010 solicitation that led to the adoption of XM556FBIT3 mentions that the ammunition will be evaluated in weapons with barrels as short as 10". A 2015 RFP (which also confirms that XM556FBIT3M was the current duty round at that time) notes that ammunition will be evaluated in 11.5" barreled rifles, including a test for optimal penetration and expansion in ballistic gelatin at 100yds. That solicitation resulted in a $15 million contract award to Vista Outdoor (Federal's parent company), and smaller awards to Winchester (presumably for RA556B) and Hornady, so I'm confident that the .223 pressure T3 load performed well in their testing. FWIW, DHS/ICE have also selected a .223 pressure T3 load with yet another unique product number as an "enhanced" duty load with a 62 grain Gold Dot-based load as their "standard" duty load. As for the original question, the .223 version will be just fine for self defense, you might lose a bit of range but as @Zhukov said it won't be much. IIRC these rounds expend reliably down the around 1800 fps. |
|
Quoted:
Damn good info @DiscipulusArmorum. As for the original question, the .223 version will be just fine for self defense, you might lose a bit of range but as @Zhukov said it won't be much. IIRC these rounds expend reliably down the around 1800 fps. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Looks like XM556FBIT3 is .223 and XM556SBCT3 is 5.56 pressure. https://www.bonefroggunclub.com/products/556-62gr-federal-tactical-bonded-xm556sbct3 https://www.targetsportsusa.com/federal-fbi-duty-556-ammo-62-grain-tactical-bonded-sp-xm556fbit3m-p-109726.aspx From what I can tell, XM556FBIT3M is indeed a .223 pressure load since both the box and the case headstamp are marked .223 REM. The FBI seems to have started purchasing this instead of the original 5.56 pressure XM556FBIT3 as early as 2015 (maybe earlier) based on some contract awards I found. I'm not totally clear on the SBC designation. Bone Frog says XM556SBCT3 is the same thing as XM556FBIT3 with the SBC simply indicating that it is not FBI-contract ammo. However in a thread from last year, a reliable source said that the current FBI contract round was .223 pressure XM223SBCT3, which throws a bit of a wrench in things as far as product numbers. He did note that they switched to the .223 load because it was more accurate. Regarding usage in SBRs, testing in short barrels has been one of the requirements for the FBI contract for almost a decade. FBI's 2010 solicitation that led to the adoption of XM556FBIT3 mentions that the ammunition will be evaluated in weapons with barrels as short as 10". A 2015 RFP (which also confirms that XM556FBIT3M was the current duty round at that time) notes that ammunition will be evaluated in 11.5" barreled rifles, including a test for optimal penetration and expansion in ballistic gelatin at 100yds. That solicitation resulted in a $15 million contract award to Vista Outdoor (Federal's parent company), and smaller awards to Winchester (presumably for RA556B) and Hornady, so I'm confident that the .223 pressure T3 load performed well in their testing. FWIW, DHS/ICE have also selected a .223 pressure T3 load with yet another unique product number as an "enhanced" duty load with a 62 grain Gold Dot-based load as their "standard" duty load. As for the original question, the .223 version will be just fine for self defense, you might lose a bit of range but as @Zhukov said it won't be much. IIRC these rounds expend reliably down the around 1800 fps. 1800 fps is the number I've generally seen given for the expansion threshold for Gold Dot/Fusion soft points. There's a Youtube video showing a calibrated gel test with reduced velocity handloads using pulled Fusion projectiles that showed robust expansion at ~1700 fps. For the the T3/Trophy Bonded soft point, I've seen numbers reported anywhere from 2000 fps to "at least 2200 fps or so". The Trophy Bonded projectile is generally considered a "tougher" bullet than the Gold Dot with slightly better performance through barriers, so the slightly higher expansion threshold would seem to be analagous to what we've seen with the optimized 50 grain TSX loaded by Black Hills. It's designed not to shed petals through auto glass like standard TSX and has a higher expansion threshold than the other TSX projectiles. |
|
Quoted: Deciphering all the various product numbers for the various FBI/T3 loadings is a bit challenging without solid info from the manufacturer. I asked our resident Federal expert for some clarification in this thread but haven't received a reply. I'm not totally clear on the SBC designation. Bone Frog says XM556SBCT3 is the same thing as XM556FBIT3 with the SBC simply indicating that it is not FBI-contract ammo. However in a thread from last year, a reliable source said that the current FBI contract round was .223 pressure XM223SBCT3, which throws a bit of a wrench in things as far as product numbers. He did note that they switched to the .223 load because it was more accurate. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
The SBC loads were intended for FBI HRT teams, who were using primarily 11.5” SBRs. The load was optimized more to reduce flash, possibly some other changes in the powder. My memory on that solicitation is a little fuzzy. I do have some of the ammo at home. Haven’t shot it yet. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted: Deciphering all the various product numbers for the various FBI/T3 loadings is a bit challenging without solid info from the manufacturer. I asked our resident Federal expert for some clarification in this thread but haven't received a reply. I'm not totally clear on the SBC designation. Bone Frog says XM556SBCT3 is the same thing as XM556FBIT3 with the SBC simply indicating that it is not FBI-contract ammo. However in a thread from last year, a reliable source said that the current FBI contract round was .223 pressure XM223SBCT3, which throws a bit of a wrench in things as far as product numbers. He did note that they switched to the .223 load because it was more accurate. |
|
Check out the link below. Good info in description that explains the nomenclature of the different FBI 5.56 and 223 loads.
XM556SBCT3 |
|
Quoted:
Check out the link below. Good info in description that explains the nomenclature of the different FBI 5.56 and 223 loads. XM556SBCT3 View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Check out the link below. Good info in description that explains the nomenclature of the different FBI 5.56 and 223 loads. XM556SBCT3 The other unanswered question is whether or not XM556SBCT3 is really the same as XM556FBIT3 as some sellers are stating. A poster above suggests the SBC load was tweaked a bit for the 11.5" guns that are now the standard FBI carbines, which makes me think it was the ammo selected in response to that 2015 solicitation. I don't ever recall seeing the SBC load for sale before then. The claim that SBC denotes a non-FBI contract load seems to be contradicted by a reliable source stating last year that the current FBI duty load was XM223SBCT3. The .223 load referenced by Eagle Eye Guns (LE223T3) is a commercial off the shelf ammo that was in use with the FBI and other state/local agencies before the FBI put out their RFP in 2010 that led to XM556FBIT3. It uses the same projectile, but is loaded in a nickel-plated case. ETA: Just wanted to note that while these minutiae are of interest to us ammo nerds, I really doubt that all these variations make any significant difference beyond a few edge cases. TBBC in any flavor is an outstanding choice. To quote DocGKR: Only after proper foundational and ongoing repetitive refresher training, cultivating warrior mind-set, and ensuring weapon system reliability do you need to worry about ammunition selection. Most folks would be far better off practicing with what they have, rather than worrying about what is "best". As long as you know what your weapon and ammo can realistically accomplish, it is all just a matter of training and shot placement. I would much rather go into battle with a guy who practices 15,000 rounds a year using generic 55 gr FMJ out of his old M16A1 than with some guy that has the latest state-of-the-art ammo and rifle, but only shoots 500 rounds a year. |
|
From the very informative posts above, I compiled the following:
XM556FBIT3: "Standard first run, USG contract 5.56 mm 62 gr bonded JSP ammo for the FBI and other Fed LE agencies is XM556FBIT3--so much for "x" meaning rejected..." DocGKR XM556FBIT3M appears to be the .223 version of XM556FBIT3. ""The 2015 solicitation I linked before notes that "Current FBI service ammunition is Federal Cartridge, 62 grain Tactical Bonded, product number XM556FBIT3M"" "Federal says its not reloads or rejects but that it is the same exact bullet/load as the fbi contract." AR15.com Some XM556FBIT3 was sold in cartons marked "Factory Seconds" in 2016. These cartridges were said to have failed to meet the FBI's accuracy requirements, and some of these cartridges purchased on the civilian market appeared to have quality issues. XM556SBCT3 appears to be a different solicitation of XM556FBIT3 that is intended for short barrel carbines. "The SBC loads were intended for FBI HRT teams, who were using primarily 11.5” SBRs. The load was optimized more to reduce flash, possibly some other changes in the powder." (Eagle Eye Guns first carried this cartridge in the summer of 2013). XM223SBCT3 appears to be the .223 version of XM556SBCT3. "... a reliable source said that the current FBI contract round was .223 pressure XM223SBCT3...He did note that they switched to the .223 load because it was more accurate." Anything missing or inaccurate? |
|
Really good terminal performance, not very accurate in anything I have. 3-4 minute ammo.
Perfect for SD. Sketchy distance load. I used to hunt it down but Fusion is a better load IMO. |
|
|
Quoted:
Wasn't Federal Fusion designed specifically for deer hunting? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Really good terminal performance, not very accurate in anything I have. 3-4 minute ammo. Perfect for SD. Sketchy distance load. I used to hunt it down but Fusion is a better load IMO. ICE is using XM223SP1PB, which seems to be virtually identical to Fusion (not sure if it uses the GMM primer though). The Trophy Bonded Bear Claw projectile used in the FBI load/Federal Tactical line started out as a hunting bullet as well. Nosler Partition and Core Lokt Ultra Bonded are two other hunting bullets with ideal characteristics for anti-felon purposes that come to mind. |
|
Quoted:
Thanks DiscipulusArmorum View Quote One thing I forgot to mention, there are two versions of Fusion. Fusion MSR is the one that is optimized for use in ARs with the aforementioned crimped, mil-spec hardness primer and better velocity in shorter barrels. Regular Fusion uses the same bullet and is by no means bad - it just doesn't have the bells and whistles that make Fusion MSR a bit better for our purposes. |
|
|
From videos I have watched, the 223 version out of a 10 inch runs 2279 ( Buffman), and out of a 10.5 the 5.56 runs 2576 (The Chopping Block). I have a couple hundred rounds of the 5.56, but I lean more to Fusion MSR.
|
|
Quoted:
From videos I have watched, the 223 version out of a 10 inch runs 2279 ( Buffman), and out of a 10.5 the 5.56 runs 2576 (The Chopping Block). I have a couple hundred rounds of the 5.56, but I lean more to Fusion MSR. View Quote |
|
I had less than favorable results when I tested the FBIT3, but that was probably almost ten years ago. During my testing of the 5.56 loads, the RA556B was the most accurate, followed by the FBIT3. As for the 223 loads, Speer 64gr won, followed closely by the xm223sp1 with the fusion bullet,really good stuff.
|
|
Quoted: I find it hard to believe that there's 300fps difference between the two loads, short of some very significant lot to lot variation or chronograph inaccuracies. The FBI contract calls for a load that meets their penetration and expansion standards (12-18" and 2x original diameter IIRC) at 100yds out of an 11.5" barrel. Given the B.C. and relatively high expansion threshold (at least compared to Gold Dot/Fusion), I don't think the .223 load could meet that requirement if it's really that slow. Or maybe it really loses a ton of velocity going from 11.5" to 10". View Quote |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.