For those lashing out at Dev for being "critical", what do you call your responses to him? I see nothing mentioned that contributes to the discussion. Rather, I see a lame two sentence reply that seems to be nothing more than someone sticking in their useless 2 cents. Unless you have something to contribute I think you should heed your own advice and "get a life".
Folks, there are subjects where BS can be tolerated and then there are topics where it cannot. Discussions about sports, politics, etc can be full of BS and it really doesn't matter all that much. But discussions about firearms and ammunition are different. The info given in such discussions may literally mean the difference between life and death for the people who receive that info. Therefore when someone posts something that's obviously nuts, the knowledgeable people of this board are going to step up and correct it. If that means being critical, then so be it. I would much rather be critical of someone's post than to allow it to stand and misinform hundreds or thousands of other readers who may not know any better. There is no room for BS info in weapon and ammo related discussions.
I hope people pay attention to certain individuals who post here. Folks like Troy, Brouhaha, Tatjana, DevL, Forest, AR15fan, ARMDLBRL and to some degree myself (although I consider myself less knowledgeable than the above mentioned people) have been here a long time and they know what they are doing. These people are a great service to the board and if they give you ammo advice, it's based on something solid that you can rely on. Now there will be times when it appears they are being critical of someone. But it is not done in an effort to discredit or humiliate someone else. It's done in an effort to protect other members of this board (both you and I) from being subjected to and unknowingly accepting BS info as fact. If these discussions lead to a better understanding of the topic, that's even better. But again, would it be responsible to allow information you know to be totally false to stand when it can easily be corrected by simply posting the facts? I think not.
I think a couple of you guys should rethink your position. Afterall, someone stepping up and being critical of bad info may someday save you money, your time, or maybe even your life.
-CH