Quoted:
I see this as more of a discussion about bullet selection. For long range high BC target bullets, the 6.5 wins–– much better selection.
The WSSM should give more velocity though.
Now mathematically, the higher BC bullet will always beat the lower BC bullet–– eventually. The larger the velocity differential between low and high BC bullets the longer it takes for high to win ballistically.
Winchester quotes 3060fps for their 115grain load. Thats with the CT bullet with a .453 BC.
Lets compare that to the AlexArms 123 gr Lapua load which is claimed at 2405fps and a .547 BC.
Thats a BIG 600 fps velocity difference (~25%), and almost about a tenth of BC diff –– ~20%.
At 600yards, thats -144" total drop for the 6.5, and -91" for the WSSM load. Thats like 37% less drop, which is significantly better. Now even if you say that the 3060 velocity is an 'optimistic' number from a 26" bolt action, the WSSM still wins by 3" less drop if it was going only 2500fps!
But really this a more of an apples and oranges thing, the WSSM is very specialized, uses a special mag, and you only get like 7 rounds, and is a barrel burner.
So that part is subjective. Looking at just the math, WSSM wins easily.
The .25 WSSM has a lot more oomph than the Grendel. I mean, just look at the case capacity! With the proper bullet, it should do fairly well at distance. I have taken 4 deer with one, and shot it out to 500 yards. This was when they first released it. Accuracy was good, but I was not real impressed by the performance of the factory loads on deer. Yes, it killed them, but they all tended to take off like the devil himself was after them upon being hit. They'd run straight out for 100 yards or so and pile up in a heap. Hardly any blood, and it would take a bit to find them.
As a sidenote, the quoted AA 123 grain velocity is too low. Even for a 14.5 inch gun that figure is low. Even so, the Grendel is no magnum.