A customer sent us his upper after a minor mishap during load development. While coming up with a good load for the 300 gr Barnes X Spitzer, he got a little impatient (he admitted to it) and loaded a bit on the adventurous side. The round fired but failed to extract and he could not get the bolt open. We got it open with a little "encouragement" and this is what the case looked like
Note the "belt" on the case as a result of the over pressure
Note the totally flat primer. The headstamp is barely legible and you can see where brass was forced into both the ejector and extractor openings.
Now, since we came out with the .458 SOCOM, several people including highly respected industry professionals have commented that we were foolish to choose the rim size we did AND neck the case down. It was stated that the bolt would not hold up to the bolt thrust, however, this load produced 30% overpressure and the bolt is just fine. Also, note that the case held up and did not fail or collapse, as we were told might happen as well. By choosing the larger rim, enough material remains at the base of the case to prevent that from happening. So despite all the people saying we were wrong, I think the proof is in the pudding ....