I bought a Bushmaster (from the new factory) back around Christmas time, before I knew a whole lot about ARs. While I can't speak much about the Windham Weaponry guns, I have to say that my bushy is outstanding. Being from a ban-state, there were only a handful of compliant guns that I could buy, so I ended up with a Bushmaster. Fit and finish on my rifle is excellent, even better than the various Windham's that I have handled at the gun stores. 1000+ rounds down range with no malfunctions so far (of course 1000 rounds isn't very much yet). I'll have to agree with the bushmaster magazines being junk. The 10 round SS mag mine came with was much flimsier than the aluminum D&Hs I bought, and although I havent had any problems with that magazine yet, I'm hesitant to use it. My only gripe with my bushmaster is the "izzy" muzzle brake on it. It's loud as all get out and doesn't do much in the way of compensation, although I don't think it looks bad. I could have gotten a jewel, but I would say that either the current bushmasters or the windham weaponry rifles are both a solid choice. With Colt's being priced how they are right now, of course I would consider that the way to go, but if a Colt is out of the question (Colt ban compliant rifles in MA go for 3-400 more than I bought my bushmaster for), then the bushmasters are GTG.