I've got a 16oz (i think it is) jar of Slip 2000 Carbon Cutter, and I find I have to leave my AR15 bolt parts in there for a minimum of 3 hours for it to have any real effect on built-up or caked-on carbon deposits. In 15 minutes, it will take the thin layers of carbon off of anything. It either comes off in the solution or wipes off afterwards. The heavy carbon deposits still need scrubbing. Best thing to do is scrub once, soak for 3 hours, scrub again, soak for an hour, scrub the rest off. Or leave it in overnight. It will take off the finish of some parts though, so anything external with a finish I would not leave in long.
I just got a bottle of Break Free Carbon Killer this afternoon, and I am going to try that instead to see if it is any better at the heavy deposits.
- rem