Fulton has a "med. wt." 1/12 for the A2 shown on their web site. The Fulton p/n is FA-AR-300-050A2 and is described as "Barrel, 20in GI, 1x12, M16A2, Chrome Lined".
And yes, they are skinny under the hand guard, and larger in front of the FSB, i.e. "govt. profile". The park was very dry, and some shelf wear of the finish is evident, but this is not for a safe queen anyway. "New" when the item has sat around for 15 or 20 years does not mean "mint, factory perfect" to me, so I feel it was worth the $.
I have a RRA A4 upper to install it on for a "vintage varminter" look with the M16 triangular handguards. The barrel has a snug fit, and no detectable play once the pin is in the slot. A compact 4x needs selected, and will sit in Leupold Mk4 rings.
They also now are showing a 1/7 A2 tube by FN on their web site, FWIW.
Paladin