Quoted:
Not really to do with this video or the person selling his educational services in this particular video.
Having seen a bunch of videos from supposed educators in the survival field, I often wonder what qualifies them to educate others, especially given the goofy advice they sometimes give. I know some of the goofiness (like carrying tampons or condoms) is as much marketing as anything practical, so I don't worry too much about that.
But the idea that one can use a few feet of wire as a snare to catch food by someone who has never done it is ludicrous. Having talked to a few people who have actually snared food, I have come to the conclusion that you would be lucky to catch one critter in 20 snares in a day. And the little survival fishing kit - just try catching some fish with it. It is possible, but people who actually have real fishing gear often catch nothing. I also get that the snares and fishing kit even though not all that practical are sort of traditional more than useful. In any case, the components don't take up much room and may well be useful for other things.
Really, food gathering is such a low priority in any short term survival situation that I wonder why people who should know better still even bother to mention it.
That’s a good question on “instructor qualifications”. I know some who were certified Army SERE instructors or have other similar qualifications. However, I wouldn’t discount some of the “lay” instructors. Kevin is a great example of one who’s always been an outdoorsman and continued to improve his skills and is now a “certified” instructor at the WLC; good schools don’t allow just anybody to instruct. I do agree though, when talking about the art of snaring, fishing and even hunting. Knowing how to read the game activity in an area is much more important; same with fishing, you need to know how to read the source, underwater structure, feeding and hiding spots. I don’t care how much instruction you get, this is best learned through practice, practice, practice. Fishing is a great example. I can get skunked fishing for bass in my little lake, but know exactly where to snag a dozen or so smaller pan fish with a simple hand line:
Every day hike we go on near water sources, I’ll pack along our little fishing kit…it is great practice and my son enjoys it. Here was a great little swimming/fishing hole we hiked to in Central Texas…we fished before we swam
Your points are valid though. I suck at making expedient snares or at least maybe it’s a mental thing, but I have much better success with regular snares. The biggest challenge is to read which game trails are more active and identifying which burrows are vacant or potentially occupied.
Quoted:
Rock6,
Thanks brother! When you get a chance, can you post up your M6 or papoose rifle kit? I know you're using a zippered pouch and you have some useful gear on the outside. I think others including myself would benefit from your user input considering your background and time behind the trigger. What do you carry in it?
I’ll have to dig them up and see if I have any photos on my personal computer since I’m vacationing here in Afghanistan. The Papoose has the stock pouch with a better kit, but my Scout is mainly set up just for on-board ammo. I’m not the greatest hunter, but with enough patience and practice, you can put meat on the table. I prefer trot lines, fish snares and small game snares…active hunting can be time consuming and not always productive depending on your area. I popped this 50 pound beaver in the head from about 10 feet with my M6 Scout, the .22LR put him in his death-throws, but the little .410 buckshot stilled him:
Quoted:
I'd like to see some practical applications for the glue stick. Sounds like a great idea!
I’ve found them to work on tarps…you just need a bead to fill in smaller holes for repairing. Sealing up and waterproofing a crack on your GPS; used with a little duct/100mph tape, it can be used to seal up a tear or crack on your kayak/raft. Although it didn’t last, it was a good temporary fix for the sole of my daughter’s shoe when hiking. I haven’t tried, but heard somebody fixed a hydration bladder with a glue stick. My wife said you could use it to glue a temporary patch of material to fix a large tear in clothing. If you understand this isn’t JB Weld, you’re only limited by your imagination.
ROCK6