Maybe it's what you're saying in the oral boards that is busting you out. The words community, serve, help, community, assist, facilitate, community, mentor, roll-model, community should be coming out of your mouth with frequency....seeing a pattern here?
Ixnay on being uber-tactical dude. They don't want to hear about how you are a 5th Dan in Malljitsu and go to Gunsite every other week to do Bill Drills on Osama IDPA targets.
Some agencies look real hard at financial responsibility, so check your credit history as well.
Small PDs go kinda ape-shit over lots of nickle-dime crap that larger agencies could care less about.
Case in point: My agency's current background questionaire is 2 pages long. We have over 1,000 sworn officers. Itty-bitty town north of us with about 30 sworn has a background questionaire that is 20+ pages. I've known guys that got hired on with that PD and had the background investigators call their middle-shcool teachers.
YMMV.
Sheep