Quoted:
I disagree with Ben Dover, Tolkien was a very devout Christian.
The Three Elven rings are a symbol of the Trinity.
The "One" ring was for the One.
The Seven Dwarf rings were for the seven Deadly sins.
There are a lot more allusions but I don't remember them all.
Gandalf is actually an Angel sent down to Earth to help us, whearas Saurman is a fallen angel.
It is really there if you can find it, Frodo is very similar to Galahad in search of the Holy Grail.
View Quote
To most of this, I say- "Hogwash"
Tolkien was a devout Christian, true, but as far as allegorical(seven for seven deadly sins) imagery, it's not there. Tolkien stated that , unlike his good bud and fellow Inkling C.S. Lewis, "I dislike allegory whenever I smell it!"
Read the Silmarillion, and notice that Tokien created a complete universe, with a single god, Eru, and a hierarchy of angels, the Arda. Gandalf is roughly equivalent to an angel, and Saruman has fallen from his appointed task, true.
As far as the 3 elven rings symbolizing the Trinity, there is not a reason to beleive this, other than there are 3 of both of them. Other than that, they hardly enter into the story, same with the dwarf rings. Tolkien's world is Pre-Christ, and Tolkien's world could even be an alternate, forgottent prehistory for our own...
The Christian connection is that Tolkien's work, unlike Rowling's, is that Tolkien's underlying Theological framework is evident to the thorough reader, especially if you read the Silmarillion.
Also, unlike the Potter books, Tolkien's heros don't seel to gain power from the enemy or evil, but rather to refuse it, because it would ultimately be their downfall, despite what earthly power they might gain(see the paralell?). Their cause is just, their "magic" as it were, is of the power of the One God, Eru, granted to his earthly children and emmissaries, even as Sauron, fallen as he is, had his power granted at the dawn of time, by Eru.
It's something of a stretch to the casual book skimmer, but Tolkien's books certainly stand in stark contrast to the world, magic, and overall message of D&D.
Juggernaut