The Wind,
I was not there, and do not claim to be an authority on the battle, but the story seemed to follow the book fairly accurately. I did not see a lot of representation of the other services besides the 75th, Delta, and 160th SOAR, but the book centered mainly on the combatants during the mission of 3 OCT. Perhaps you could be a little more detailed about his objections??? That could shed some light.
Based on my coversations with some of the guys in 3/75 who were there, it must have been a terrible place to be-an absolute meat grinder. I have total respect for all who served there, and I can understand how a movie depicting the events might be difficult to bear.
The treatment of the C.O.B. (civialian on the battlefield) issue was slightly dealt with. At one point a Somali women approaches a group of Rangers-apparently unarmed. She then pulls a weapon from beneath her robes and is dumped by a SAW gunner. The scenes of masses of people running down the street towards the outnumbered troops, and of the final scene as the guys complete the "Mogadishu Mile" with the burning cars, tires, and a horde of people in the background was very affecting.
There are some reviews already posted on some of the sites. I would recommend checking those out as they get into plot development and characters.
I don't think the movie glamorized the events. Everyone in the screening room (I think I was the only one in the military, past or present) was taken aback and shocked at the brutality and unbelievable odds those guys were up against. The guys were certainly portrayed as heroic, but who here would argue that point?
Wait until you can see the movie: check out the scene where Shugart and Gordon secure Durant's bird, fight to the end, are killed and dragged out, and tell me if was glamorized.
I won't say I enjoyed the movie, but as a former member of the 75th, I'm glad the story is being told in a way that honors those that died there.