I wear it. I think it's a great idea. I've been standing along a tree, covered head-to-toe in blaze orange and watched a rafter of turkey walk with in 20 steps...and move on, two doe and three yearlings follow the same path as the turkey...and move on, and a coyote came by ten minutes later on the same trail (now remember, I was down wind of the trail).
It's the law...it's another rule...it's a something else to remember (don't forget your license)...
When you are hunting...it's MOVEMENT not color. The folks who say it scares game off are probably unaware that they moved a fraction or that something near their blind/location seemed out of place to the critter(s)...many times the wind shifts and you never know it...the animal bolts and the hunter WAS perfectly still.
I use it turkey hunting too...I wrap it around the tree I'm sitting under...especially when I use a decoy.
Hey, it's your life. You wanna leave it off, be my guest. I don't give a hoot what somebody's "statistics" say or what the "pioneers" looked like when they hunted...I'm gonna stand out to other hunters. I WANT to be seen. I want those folks who I can't see (the ones who "by God" won't wear the stuff) to see me a long way off. If you hunt public land...you are really taking a risk.
Geez, look at it this way, any hunter who is considerate of other hunters won't "ease on in" to your hunting area if he/she can see you. Look at it as hunter repellent!
VF