Goatboy has already said, in another thread, that it is not possible to give members the date the joined the old board. I was on that board as well but don't remember when I joined. I do think that showing when someone joined this board is a good idea though. The board is new enough now that it really doesn't matter much. But in a couple of years it will matter to some.
Post totals I think are important. Goatboy has said he will bring those back as soon as he gets the chance.
I think most of the people that are complaining that post totals or when anyone registered are only those with few post that registered recently.
But I don't see why we can't have both. Other boards do.
I registered on Glocktalk three years ago or so. But I've got less than a hundred post there. Am I a contributing member there? No, not really.
I started my own board less than a year ago. So do I have a lot of time there? No, no one does. It is too new for anyone to have been there long. But I have over 2000 post there. So am I a contributing member there. You bet.
I registered on TFL almost three years ago and have over 2300 post there. I am (was before being banned) a contributing member there.
Registeration date or post total neither one alone really tells anyone much about a person. And even combined they can not tell a person if the member has contributed anything constructive to the board. That can only be learned from reading the persons post and getting to know them.
But post totals and registeration can tell others a lot about the other person. Do they participate? Do they really know the people on the board? Are they really a part of the board and do they think of it as their "home on the 'net"?
BTW, having to look them up is nice and fine.....and a pain in the ass. Especially when the software allows for it to be posted next to the user name.