It's possible that your meter was "estimated" the last month and usage was guesstimated on what you used last year and this years weather conditions.
What kind of electrical appliances are being used at this time? I'd assume a furnace, and maybe a few lights? Is there a refrigerator running? Water pump?
Your bill seems a bit high if it's empty, were there tracks in the snow or any evidence of someone plugging a cord in? Does the house next door have a "red tag" on the elec meter signifying it's been turned off for non pay? Is the lockwing under the gas meter turned off and bulleted next door[pinned]?
Could some appliance like a refrig been left open?
It's been cold, you said you had a elec thermostat, does this mean you have Nat gas or elec heat? The furnace should only use $10 or so of electricity a month if it's run quite frequently, much less if it's only kicking on occasionally, it could draw a lot more if there is a problem with the bearings [bushings] in the blower wheel if its a belt drive, the starting circuit could be kicking on and off to keep RPMs up to speed.
Check your read tho, read RIGHT to LEFT, put down the numbers the same way, if the dial is on the 9 and the next one to the left is on, say, the one, the correct read for that number would still be zero, if nothing else call the utility company and ask for a re read as you believe it's been read wrong. Check for an "EST" by the read on The bill first, an "ACT" will be there is a reader read it.
Is it DTE or Consumers?