Sensible approachJail-based immigration enforcement is focused and practicalFeb. 09, 2006
www.charlotte.com/mld/observer/news/opinion/13826392.htmThe effort to combat illegal immigration launched by Mecklenburg County Sheriff Jim Pendergraph and U.S. Rep. Sue Myrick of Charlotte is a welcome, and sensibly limited, way to deal with a tough problem.
Enforcement of immigration law is a federal job, and the federal government isn't doing it. Our borders are porous. Federal efforts to determine who's here illegally are ineffective. Congress seems more interested in debating about illegal immigration than deterring it. Local police don't want to take on immigration law enforcement because they don't have the mandate or the money for it. In addition, they're concerned with deterring crimes against people and property, and they fear if they're seen as enforcers of immigration law they'll lose contacts in the immigrant community they need to combat theft, assault, drug dealing and the like.
That's why the new program's focus makes sense. It trains sheriff's officers to check the immigration status of persons brought to the county jail on criminal charges, using a federal database of photographs, fingerprints and other information. Those who lack documentation and have been deported before or have been arrested for serious crimes will be turned over to federal officials for possible deportation.
This approach avoids a number of potential problems. It won't be funded by local tax dollars but by federal money the jail collects for housing federal prisoners. The enforcement effort will take place in the jail, not on the streets, so there's no appearance of a local police sweep through immigrant communities. The Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department, whose officers have the primary law enforcement duties in this county, won't be involved, so immigrants will have no reason to think the officer on the street is doubling as an immigration investigator.
Local authorities won't solve our nation's immigration problem. But when illegal immigrants are arrested for crimes here, it makes sense to kick them out of the country.
The larger problem of illegal immigration is a federal responsibility. Trying to solve it through local police work is about like trying to stop a flood by putting on hip boots.