Quoted:
Quoted: I didn't care for the book. It started off as a good read but I found myself disagreeing with him in later chapters.
|
Me too, I forgot what I disagreed with, but the book left me with a bad impression. Grossman had an axe to grind about something.
|
I disagreed with his use of the "x many serviceman shot" study. Buddy of mine sent me some stuff showing that the study that only 25% give or take of guys in WW2 combat fired. That was BS. Which, of course, effects the conclusions of Grossman's studies about increase in violence.
However, I think the book still has a lot to give on the psychological aspects of violence and killing, and what it does to people. If you go looking for those parts, it's well worth the read.
Also, I've heard
On Combat is fantastic. I'm told he goes right down to what combat stress physically does to you. Heart rate, tunnel vision, slow time, etc. One quote I read about it is where he talks to a cop who kept recalling that somebody was throwing beer cans marked "FEDERAL" on them at him during a shoot out. He couldn't figure out what he had been seeing, but that was the only way he could describe it. Turned out he was seeing his ejected brass go by his shoulder. Also why soldiers seem to recall things in slow motion, and such. He goes into why that happens, physically and psychologically.