Here's something to chew over this morning:
The Florida Times-Union
October 1, 2005
Water tower's bright cross heads to tense court battleBy JEFF BRUMLEY
The Times-Union
STARKE -- Anita Patterson and her dachshund Jodee were strolling up Christian Street Wednesday morning when she was asked about the 100-foot tall, silver city-owned water tower standing just yards away.
Yes, the one just off U.S. 301 with the 10-foot lighted cross perched on top.
"Without that cross we wouldn't know our way home," Patterson said, explaining she means that literally, because she lives nearby, and spiritually, because she is a Christian.
"To me, what it is, especially being up that high -- the cross is a lighthouse," she said.
But to a local atheist and a national atheists' civil rights organization, the cross wrongly declares Christianity as an official religion, and they are suing in federal court in Jacksonville to have it taken down.
"They put the cross up to intimidate people, that's my opinion," said Lon Bevill, a Bradford County resident and atheist who lives just outside the city limits.
New Jersey-based American Atheists Inc. shares that opinion and is financing litigation in which the organization and Bevill are plaintiffs. They say the cross violates the federal and the state constitutions.
"Every time he sees the cross, he feels alienated and demeaned by a sense that in the eyes of the community, his absence of religious belief renders him a second-class citizen," the lawsuit says of Bevill, 64.
The lawsuit seeks a permanent injunction requiring the city to remove the cross and reimburse attorney fees.
City Manager Ken Sauer said Starke will respond to the lawsuit, "but I don't know when."
Sauer, City Commissioner Larry Davis and Library Director Phalbe Henrickson said they don't know when the cross was erected or by whom.
"We're researching that," Sauer said.
Davis said the cross has been there at least 40 years.
"It really has been up there so long nobody remembers," Henrickson said.
A 1999 Miami Herald story said a Starke mayor put the cross up in the 1950s.
Sauer confirmed the lawsuit's claim that there have been previous complaints about the cross.
Mayor Carolyn Spooner and City Attorney Terrence Brown did not return phone calls seeking comment.
But Davis didn't shy away from expressing his support for the cross and his disgust for the lawsuit.
"It really makes you mad to know someone wants to take something down that represents Christ on the cross," Davis said.
He estimated at that least 75 percent of the city's approximately 9,500 residents attend church -- including himself.
"I'm a born-again Christian and I will stand behind the community," Davis said. "If the community wants that left up there, then we will stand toe-to-toe and fight whoever we have to fight."
Over on Christian Street, Patterson said she hadn't heard that a lawsuit had been filed. She suggested an easy solution for Bevill.
"Ignore it, just don't look at it," she said. "It's not like we're forcing Christianity and the Bible on you."
But David Silverman, a spokesman for the American Atheists, said it does force a particular religion on non-believers and people of other faiths, and violates the law.
"They have churches and they have places for that," he said about displays of crosses and other religious symbols.
"And it doesn't matter if 99.9 percent of them are Christian, they don't get to choose to break the law, especially federal law," Silverman said.
At a restaurant near the water tower Wednesday morning, Bevill explained that he has lived in the area since the 1970s and has complained to city officials before about the cross.
He says his opposition has fueled such strong tensions that he felt the need to buy a gun for protection.
With a full head of white, wavy hair, dark blue eyes and a deep voice, the former pilot and aircraft mechanic explained that he got fed up and contacted American Atheists after recently meeting other people in town who felt intimidated by the symbol.
"I just figured it was time," Bevill said.
jeff.brumleyjacksonville.com, (904) 359-4310
@You can learn more at about American Atheists at www.atheists.org
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There's a picture that accompanies this article with Bevill holding a pistol with the water tower in the background. I really don't have an opinion about whether the cross should stay or go, but I'm trying to figure out why the reporter would have Bevill pose in such a way.
Bevill
BTW, this is Florida we're talking about here. Dude, that's a tiny gun.