My brother and friend and I are planning a canoe trip in the Boundary Waters for next summer. We were talking supplies and routes and packs and portages and other miscellaneous details when firearms came up. My brother is going to bring his Smith & Wesson Mountain Gun (4" .44 magnum, stainless). My buddy Mike is bringing his Glock 21 (45 ACP) in a Fobus belt holster. He says even if it gets wet, who cares? So, what should I bring? Things to consider:
Weight: I am going to be carrying a 40-50 lbs pack for a couple of long portages. It would be nice to have a lighter pistol (but not really a make it or break it point).
Water: Chances are this gun is going to get at least a little wet. Between canoes and possible rain, everything gets damp at a minimum. Rust resistance would be nice.
Power: This is the Boundary Waters. Who knows what we might have to shoot? A moose? A black bear? A sasquatch? I would like something bigger than a .22, just in case!
Current options:
Kimber Custom II. It's my daily carry, and reliable as an old whore. I don't really care if I bang her around, or if we lose some bluing. It's already got a lot of character; more won't hurt. 45 ACP is, of course, a fine caliber, although any handgun round from a semiauto is a bit anemic for use against wildlife. Kramer cowhide vertical scabbard.
Smith & Wesson Model 28. 4" .357 magnum. I like my .357; it's a good woods round. She's accurate and reliable and while it wouldn't be my first choice for shooting a black bear or a moose in an emergency, I wouldn't feel totally undergunned, either. However, this pistol is the closest thing I have to a safe queen. I mean, I use it, but this pistol is absolutely gorgeous. No scratches, immaculate blueing, beautiful custom rosewood grips. If we dumped the canoe, I might shed a tear over rust on this pistol. El Paso Saddlery Threepersons holster.
Or one of a couple of 9mms. I've also got a SIG P226 and a Glock 26, but 9mm just doesn't give me much confidence unless I'm facing a human target. I think I want more punch on this trip. I"m leaning against these two. I do have kydex belt holsters for both.
So, what's your vote? Or, do I need to buy something else altogether? A S&W 629 with a 5" barrel? A Glock 20 in 10mm? (I want both of these, but money is an issue!) Share your thoughts.