By MICHAEL GRABELL, KRISTEN HOLLAND and JASON TRAHAN / The Dallas Morning News
A fight that ended with a gunman rising out of the sunroof of a moving Jaguar and killing three people early Tuesday apparently began an hour earlier at a college bar where police have had to use a Taser and a pepper-ball gun to quell rowdy Monday night crowds.
JOHN DAVID EMMETT/ Special Contributor
Friends Tonya Hernandez (left) and Marcela Castillo, 17, consoled each other Tuesday morning as friends of the victims gathered at the site of the shootings near Mockingbird and Central Expressway. "It has a history of fights every Monday night at close," said a police report from an incident last week at Jack's Pub and Volleyball Club on Yale Boulevard. Each week on that day, the club hosts a party for area bar and restaurant employees who have to work Friday and Saturday nights.
Killed at North Central Expressway and Mockingbird Lane were Eddie Pech, a 36-year-old chef, and two cousins, Bernardo Andrade, a 21-year-old bouncer, and Favio Andrade, a 19-year-old deli cashier. Another man, Osvaldo Juarez, was in critical condition Tuesday night at Baylor University Medical Center.
About 9 a.m., police found the Jaguar suspected in the shootings at Belgrade Avenue near Parkdale Park in Pleasant Grove. Dallas police were interviewing the victim of an earlier bar fight and another man Tuesday evening, but no arrests had been made.
The fight that led to the shootings began about 1 a.m. when someone hit a 21-year-old man on the head with a beer bottle, a Dallas police report said.
A man working at the bar who asked not to be identified said two off-duty Dallas police officers paid to watch the parking lot were on hand when a fight broke out in the club.
"It was a 'You bumped into me, I bumped into you' type fight," the worker said. "They had words, and before you know it, they're fighting in the bar and got thrown out."
A man injured in the bar fight tried to use his arm to defend himself and was cut on his left wrist, the police report said. The worker at the bar said the man and three friends left in a white Jaguar.
Shortly after the bar closed at 2 a.m., the Jaguar closed in on the 1996 navy blue Ford Crown Victoria driven by the shooting victims on a southbound access road to Central Expressway.
Two Dallas police officers who witnessed the shooting said a man stood up through the sunroof of the Jaguar with a high-powered rifle – possibly an AK-47-style automatic weapon – and opened fire on the other car as it approached Mockingbird Lane near Southern Methodist University.
The shots were fired in University Park, but the car crossed over Mockingbird Lane and struck a guardrail in Dallas. The homicides became University Park's first since 2002.
Monday night specials
Jack's Pub and Volleyball Club, a hangout for Southern Methodist University students, has had several fights on Tuesday mornings as the bar closes, police reports show.
Courtesy
From top: Favio Andrade, Bernardo Andrade and Eddie Pech. On Oct. 19 – another Tuesday at 2 a.m. – police used a pepper-ball gun to disperse several crowds that were fighting. On Monday nights, the club is open to patrons 18 and older and has two DJs, $2 drinks and $4 pitchers.
In 2004, there were 125 police calls to Jack's Pub.
Those included 23 offense reports for assaults, auto thefts and car burglaries. The figures include less-serious incidents such as lost-property reports and public intoxication. They also include incidents in front of the club and in a parking lot shared by other businesses.
In comparison, the Across the Street Bar, across from Jack's Pub, had one offense report in 2004. Have a Nice Day Cafe in the West End had 49, Trees in Deep Ellum had two. A northwest Dallas business that city attorneys sued over security problems – Club DMX on Spangler Road – had 86 incident reports.
Last week, police at Jack's Pub had to fire a Taser as a warning to break up a crowd that was about to fight.
Dirk Kelcher, who owns Jack's Pub with his twin, Mark, said the club attracts a diverse clientele on Monday nights and employs 15 security guards and at least two off-duty police officers to control crowds leaving the bar. The club isn't much different from other popular nightspots in Dallas' entertainment districts when it comes to fights, he said.
"We've had our fair share – probably less than most other bars," he said. "There's always going to be people that rub each other the wrong way."
In January 2002, a man was shot on an early Tuesday morning as he was riding away from the club in a car. Police said the victim was involved in a disturbance with a bar patron and was shot when the car stopped at a traffic light on Greenville Avenue.
Also Online
3 fatally shot after fight at Dallas bar
Friends had a rare night out together
Graphic: How it happened
Video: Gary Reaves reports
En español: Balacera deja tres muertos y un herido
A memorial fund for Eddie Baltazar Pech has been established at Wells Fargo Bank. Call 214-692-8193 to make a donation.
Mr. Kelcher said that the club has been having parties on Monday nights for more than 10 years and that the police do a good job of dispersing the crowds quickly so fights don't break out.
About 500 people went to Jack's Pub throughout the night Monday. Whenever a big fight happens, security comes to his office in the club and notifies him. No one did that Monday, he said.
The triple homicide is unusual for University Park, a usually quiet enclave inside Dallas. The last homicide occurred in 2002, when 64-year-old osteopath Ronald Stegman was found beaten to death in his Colgate Avenue home.
Mike Kelly, owner of the Cobblestone Shoe Hospital at Mockingbird and Central Expressway, said he isn't worried about what happened outside his storefront Tuesday.
"I worry here, being on a corner, of being robbed," Mr. Kelly said. "I've had one break-in in 17 years. It's pretty well lit up. It stays well-patrolled" by police officers.
None of the victims was affiliated with Southern Methodist University, but SMU police issued a campus alert Tuesday about the off-campus shooting. The alert urges anyone with information to contact police.
The Dallas officers who witnessed the shooting were transporting a prisoner but stopped to help the victims, whose car crashed near the former Mrs Baird's bread factory.
The department's general orders allow officers who have a prisoner in their car to handle another police incident if "it is of such magnitude as to place life or property in jeopardy."
Police did not find a gun in the Jaguar impounded from the Pleasant Grove home but are conducting forensic tests.