User Panel
Posted: 10/23/2004 7:05:02 PM EDT
Opinions? Worth it?
I still can not for the life of me understand why Ruger does not make a Mini-14 that will take AR-15 magazines. Anyway, Buy or Pass? |
|
Their good for the money - I paid $150 for mine used many years ago. I wouldn't waste $450 on a new one if I could get an AR for a few hundred more.
|
|
|
|
|
YES... And it didn't work in either... |
|
|
Pass. How much more would you have to save for an AR? There's no contest between the two.
Edit: Even an AK is much better in my very humble opinion. |
|
it's a shit-kicker. i wouldn't pay too much for one. accuracy may vary. widely.
|
|
I had one and sold it,because I couldn't hit jack with it. My dad has one that is pretty accurate. I would pass and build an AR.
|
|
+1 but if you can get it for cheap.... |
|
|
PASS...I have one,its not very accurate...I'm gonna sell mine and get an AR.(another AR that is!).
|
|
Buy it, one more for the collection but you can expect 3" at 50y if you are lucky.
|
|
where's that 'not this shit again' pic (for the mini-14 bashers).
Posting on the wrong forum to be asking about Mini-14s. - Go read a little here - www.perfectunion.com/forums/index.php?showforum=55 |
|
Here's the deal with Mini-14s.
First problem: the barrel, accuracy Pencil-thin barrel that also happens to be at a length that is a harmonic for the .223 round. Also, there are a lot of people that swear the last two inches of barrel are really crappy for some reason. Second problem: The magazine area of the gun, reliability The dimensions for the mag catch are ALL OVER THE PLACE, and there is a good possibility that other stuff varies too. There was an article floating around the net written by a 'smith who was doing some mini-14 work and discovered that the mag-catch dimensions varried widely. He ordered 7 or so mag catches from brownells and measured them, finding large discrepancies. Whatever the problem, I have mags that I have tweaked to work in my mini, that didn't work when I tried them in a different mini! Where is the quality control at? For a variety of reasons the mini-14 has a major weakness and reliability problems with respects to magazines. I'd pass and get an SKS or AK. They'll still probably beat the mini in accuracy too. When I get outta Kali, first thing I'll do is sell my mini and get something better. Ruger really has their head up their ass on this one. If they made a QUALITY mini-14 with a few minor upgrades/chagnes...say selling for 700-800, everyone and their brother would rush down to the fun-store to buy one |
|
I would say only if it is cheap...think Choate folder btw...
|
|
Let's see...$450 for an inaccurate, unreliable rifle with absolutely no military heritage, produced by a company with dubious RKBA policies...
I'd pass, especially when the same money would get you 3 or 4 like-new Yugo SKS rifles. |
|
Yeah, like "Minute of Barn" widely. |
|
|
I don't buy garbage guns, you shouldn't either. Zen "This is my rifle, there are many like it, but this one is mine" |
|
|
you'll have to look at the big pitcure and the price of magazines.
Ruger Magazines are not cheap, PMI's are hard to come by at a decent price |
|
What happened to the ol' Arfcom spirit? You know, buy 'em all, get one of each, get both 'em. Who cares what it costs, it's a gun, dammit.
|
|
What do you want it for? Just a deal that came along? ...for that kind of green, you could get a decent CMP M1 Garand. If you just want a good working semi auto, get the SKS or the AK. If you like the hi cap and gotta have American, go with building an AR, or a FAL (Is it still legal to build FAL's?) If you just gotta have this gun...get it. Good luck |
|
|
I have one, but I won't be getting another unless it was priced so low that I couldn't refuse...
|
|
My experience with my Mini-14. This was my first firearm. I put a scope on my mini and I could not zero the rifle! It has a wandering zero. Magazines are crap! Only good ones are really expensive. I bought a Sar-1 for plinking and a Savage 10fp for accuracy and dumped my mini. I don't miss it one bit! For plinking I suggest getting an SKS/AK series rifle, or spend a little more and get an AR-15, scope options are much better.
|
|
PASS!!!!!!!!!! PASS!!!!!!!!!! PASS!!!!! AK variants are cheaper, just as accurate, have more and better accessories and are more reliable!!!!!!!!!!! ONCE AGAIN PASS!!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
I've had a Mini-14 since last summer. We had some foxes (not the lady type) hanging around during the daytime. So the fam felt it neccessary to get a foxinator. Went to the local gunstore and put down the money for a used Ranch, Simmons 3x9 scope, and some 223. Needless to say, the foxes decided to leave on their own accord.
It did get some use this summer however on some raccoons that dared to come out during the day. The one we got was either rabid... or drunk. I'm guessing rabid. It's good to live in a Town where the dispatchers only comments are "do you have the means?" Back to accuracy. I wasn't impressed with it last summer. I couldn't zero it even with the scope. However, after coming home from my 3 month oasis to Georgia this spring, I sat down with it and decided that I was going to zero it, or trade it back in. So there I sat, with the rifle comfortably slumped on an army issue cold weather sleeping back, which was in turn, comfortably slumped on a picnic bench. And so I shot. And to my surprise, I could actually see where the bullet had gone through my particle board target. I shot some more, adjusted the scope, and shot again. Three rounds at a time. Well, I'm happy to say that the Mini is zeroed. I wouldn't even attempt to take off the scope and try it with the iron sights. Tried it last summer to no avail. Probably paid to much for it in hindsight. But now I'm not one to sell any firearms, so the mini stays. I was even contemplating sending it to Accuracy Systems for an overhaul. From what their webpage tells me, they can turn a Mini into a real tack driver. Although, I have yet to hear a third party tell me about them, and putting even more money into a plinker seems not so fiscally responsible. That's why I'm going on now with 3 Pre "NY" Ban AR15's, 2 SARs (1,2), and my Remington Rangemaster (22LR) which incidently, I can put rounds though rounds My advice. Get a Mini if you really want a Mini. If you can find a cheaper alternative and aren't hell bent on a certain rifle, then skip it. |
|
pass
get an AR bushy it takes obtainable mags, reliable, ACCURATE, and nice looking |
|
Had 2 over the years. Sold or traded both very quickly. I would agree with what others have said. Accuracy is non existent. Get and AR or AK depending on what your needs are. If you could get one for about 150 for a truck gun or to leave at camp type thing fine. Otherwise pass.
|
|
Point is some are some aren't. I've yet to run into an early model 180 or 181 that was a piece of crap. I guess the tooling was still new. In those days, early 80's I actually knew SWAT members that traded their more expensive ARs for mini's to save on cash and get a rifle as acuarate as the AR at the time with fewer jam issues. Now along comes the later models and tools begin to wear at the same time volume production picks up. Process variability becomes an issue and sub 2" MOAs drop to sub 3" MOAs. Along comes Clinton's ban and the cheap mag becomes expensive. In general, those of us who have older minis love them and those of us with later model ones are best guess split 50/50. There are a number of aftermarket addons that improve the rifle many mentioned on this thread in short blurbs. If you have a later model with loose fitting wood stock converting to a nylon Choate style improves the rifle greatly. Adding a flash suppressor also changes the harmonics of the barrel by adding more mass. I can't write much about the mag issues since I have an early mini that feeds every mag I have bought including the cheap 40 round mags. I wish I could say that about my ARs. Anyway people that have mag issues with minis typically don't take their shitty mags to the range anymore than AR people with mag issues do. From a survival standpoint, they have their place mainly due to the fact they are more PC than an AR. When evacuating and open carrying a slung rifle or even car searches, the public reaction is less to the mini than the AR. It doesn't typically have the evil rifle stigma and this can make a difference to a jury during a trial in which the gun was used. Likewise when hunting varmits on public land, it draws far less attention than an AR. It has a place in a 5.56mm gun collectors collection just not a very large one. Tj |
|
|
I, too, suspect this is the case. It's more like 4-6 MOA these days. 3 MOA is the exception. It's pretty bad when a sloppy, shot-out AK with crappy russian ammo can produce as good, or better results. The really sad thing is, all ruger would have to do wold be to ship them out with a different barrel and you'd solve the problem. |
||
|
My slightly tweaked Mini shoots 1.5-2 MOA all day long, in heavy dust even.
|
|
If you can pick up a used one for a few a little outlay, pick it up.
I picked up a stainless folder with 5 factory mags for $250. It's a fun gun. I wouldn't use it but for a range plinker. |
|
Depends on the asking price and what you want it for. I bought one about 5 years ago as a fun gun and paid $425. It's a neat little carbine that's been absolutely reliable and I've tweaked cheap, crappy "Triple K" mags to the point where the haven't had a failure in all that time. I can kill clay pigeons all day out to about 40-50 yards, stay on paper to roughly 100 and can hit a torso-sized target at 200 maybe about 80% of the time. Prints a shotgun pattern at that distance but it's still a hit. It's light and pretty compact now that I've put a Butler Creek folder on it. Plus, the wife likes it and is equally good with it.
If I was going to own only one semi-auto .223, I'd pass and save up for an AR or look at an AK (esp Robinson's VEPRs). If you can dicker on the price and want something that's "adequate" and fun, go for it. For that matter, you could look at the KelTec SU16 - it takes AR mags - but I thought it felt like a flimsy POS. Good luck! |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.