What's the intended use? That should guide you in your purchase.
Before I make a large buy, I like to list out all the "I wants" and "I won't do withouts" of features/performance before choosing.
For example:
4 doors, 2 doors, 3 doors or 5
4x4 FWD RWD or AWD
MT,AT, CVT or SMG
etc, etc etc.
Once you figure out what features you refuse to do without you can dramatically narrow your selection to those products in your price range that meet your requirements. From there you can refine your choices in any number of ways. For example, when I last when shopping for a vehicle my main criteria were:
FWD or AWD, MT or SMG, 200+ bhp, under 25k, at least 2+2 seating and must be able to be serviced locally. That narrowed it down to a handful of vehicles and after comparing other "I want" options at my price point, only one car met the specs.
I would think (but could be wrong) that someone considering a JGC would not be in the market for a Wrangler...the two seem to fill different roles.