Guys,
This film sucked. The only redeeming features were the fact that they were doing a ww1 film at all, the weapon selection, and the "stuff" speech.
Ricky was embarassing.. The performance he gave belonged on Lifetime, and I surely hope the brave man he defamed will have his chance at pistol-whipping Little Ricky in the afterlife for acting such the fool.
The terrain they used only bears resemblance to the real site of the "loss" in that it is on the planet earth, and has got some trees on it. The real site was a wicked ravine, I've been there, and I've got pix I can dig out if anyone cares that much. Portrayal of the difficulty of the terrain was underdone.
Equipment was the usual Hollywood mess, with individuals turning up occasional bits of UK kit (besides the SMLE.. Caught that too, as well as a doughboy with a Mauser I believe.). On the whole, better than most though.. Certainly better than Sgt. York ;) It was nice to hear yet another honest appraisal of the Chauchaut LMG though. "The worst insult ever inflicted on the american fighting man" (*cough* next to having your commanding officer played by Ricky Fucking Schroeder).
The germans came off as poncy morons who never shot straight, the doughboys came off as simple, yet good-hearted angels who never missed. Typical cowboys and indians crap.
And finally.. WHERE THE HELL DID THAT STAFF CAR COME FROM AT THE END?!?! The tail of that film looked like they had shot it on the fly once the budget had run out with as little attention to continuity as possible. A complete afterthought.
If you want cheesy but amusing WW1 fodder, go pick up the complete 6 hour ANZACS miniseries.. You'll get to see Paul Hogan get shot at, there's a bit more historical attention, and it portrays a group of men who didn't get there late, mop up the leavings, and take all the credit. (Lots of good Lewis Gun footage too, and who doesn't love that?).
-Pvt. Sparky
5th Bn AIF (Rec'd)
200 Rounds and a Bayonet!