Quoted:
If I'm reading you correctly, should I only be allowed to have certain types of dogs as "pets"? The only thing my retriever ever retrieves is his Kong, and though I can't speak dog, I'm quite sure he is content with his life as a "pet". In fact, I would be surprised if you could name a handful of dogs, other than the little floofy ones that you spoke of that were originally bred to be "pets", yet they have all found their way into backyards across the world as nothing more than "pets" and regular dogs. Not having enough time to exercise him is one issue, but telling me I shouldn't get a hunting dog because I don't hunt is ridiculous. Sorry to gripe, but your post kinda rubbed me as a little pretentious.
View Quote
Pardon, I would not deign (though you DID ask) to tell you what to get. I am only attempting to offer good advice. I am a bit of a curmudgeon over the way (please think big picture here) that non-hunters have, for decades, bought sporting breeds and subsequently destroyed them via "backyard breeding." Your golden, as a breed, were once splendid hunters. Now they are barely capable of being housebroken--again, as a breed, not individuals. Beagles can scarcely run a rabbit, and are very, very prone to epilepsy and other genetic shortcomings (ever see a "parrot-mouth" dog?) that should have been ruthlessly culled out--and were for many generations. The things that make hunting breeds effective as hunters also make them into good pets--biddability, overall disposition, low dominance, conformity, coat, etc. Many breeds have been ruined by the pet industry--English bulls cannot have their pups w/o a C-section, epilepsy is rampant, hip dysplasia is rampant in larger breeds, various exaggerated traits have been sought, and bred for, to the detriment of various breeds. The most recent is the huge number of Dalmations that have ended up in the shelters because they are HORRIBLE with children--despite the stupid movie. They were originally bred to guard fire trucks from thieving urchins--NOT as companions. They are high-strung and temperamental and very prone to biting. Not good for homes with children. I stand by my words, but could have been a bit more diplomatic. I apologize.