User Panel
Posted: 8/22/2017 2:18:10 PM EDT
After getting a few quotes for lawn service, I've decided to just bite the bullet and mow it myself (at least until my son can). I was looking to purchase a garden tractor initially, but a few friends have suggested looking at a zero turn, stating that it would save me at least 20-30% in time. I own 2.5 acres of relatively flat land, with the exception of a 1/4 acre pond surrounded by trees every 35 feet.
I've also been told to skip the residential mowers and "buy once, cry once" with a commercial quality option. Therefore, I've been looking at the Swisher, Cub Cadet, Husqvarna, Hustler, Dixie, and Toro. I'm suffering from a little bit of sticker shock, but it should pay for itself within 2-3 years, especially with 0% financing. Does anyone have any opinions about whether I should go with a zero turn vs. a garden tractor? The additional functionality of the garden tractor seems cool, but I don't really foresee myself plowing snow with a tractor. If I'm going to save 30 minutes of my weekend Any thoughts on any particular brand? Engine choice? ZTR vs. Tractor? How much to spend? Things to avoid? |
|
Craigslist, commercial zero turn. There's a shitton of clapped out junk, but you might find something good. I picked up a 2014 Gravely ZT42XL with 300hrs for $1500 a few months ago.
|
|
I use a residential 2007 Troy-Bilt Super Bronco 42" mower to mow a 3 acre yard for someone. His property is all up the side of a steep hill with no flat land at all. I replaced the rear tires with the tractor style tires instead of turf tires. Total time is about 2.5 hours to mow all of it.
The thing with MTD equipment is the parts across the brands are the same and they make the same model for years, meaning the parts are plentiful and cheap. A mower is a machine, it is going to wear out. You will have to replace blades, belts, spindles, springs...etc on anything that you will buy if you use it enough. On a residential yard, that might get cut once a week, the residential tractors are more than enough. Craigslist a used one of these for $350 and call it a day. |
|
A Garden Tractor is only useful if you're going to plow, till, level or handle snow regularly. Nothing currently in the market I could recommend but lots of old stuff like "power kings" "Case 446" "Deere 450" etc out there that is built to last many more years if maintained.
Zero turns are quick one trick ponies.. Make sure you're looking at one with as wide a deck as possible and yes a used commercial will outlast a brand new box store one. I mow ~ 3 acres of the 10 we have with a Troy Bilt Pony 42in mower. Takes about 2hrs IF I keep up with it. The mower came with the house and is small for what we have to mow but works. As long as that lasts and I have kids that do the work I'm going to keep it. When it breaks down I'll get a used commercial ZTM. |
|
I can mow 4 acres in a couple hours with a scag turf tiger and a 72" deck.
It depends on how much you enjoy mowing. I hate it, so I got the big deck, and scags are built like a tank. I do have a hilly uneven area I mow, so when the deck is tilted left or right, the grass has some uneven cuts. if you are a yard nut, a smaller deck will give you a more even cut in those areas. |
|
Also, zero turns are great for whipping around trees, but when your inside tire isn't rolling, it is tearing up the grass.
I just want it cut and don't care much about how it looks, so it is not an issue for me. |
|
|
I mowed 6 acres that had a lot of trees to go around (15 - 20) and it took 45 minutes with my 50" cut 20HP Dixie Chopper, that time included checking oil and topping off the gasoline. Or you could spend 4 hours + with a "lawn tractor"
|
|
I mow a healthy 2 acres. I have a 42" cub cadet tractor. Get a zero turn. Mine takes about 3 hours to do it all. I bet a zero turn could knock it to 1 hour.
I have never used my mower for anything but mowing. |
|
|
I have about 3 acres of seriously uneven and hilly yard.
I went the lawn tractor route instead of lawn mower route due to deck height. It takes about 2hrs but like I said it is not your average lawn. Never really took it that a lawn tractor was good for anything but lawns. I know they make Garden Tractors that are bigger and would be useful for other things. |
|
A zero turn will be the fastest option unless you go with a large finish mower. I have 2 acres, and a Toro Zmaster that is 62" wide. Mow time is 35min with trees and tight areas that slow me down a bit.
|
|
The old place had three acres of heavy pasture grass on a mostly level yard. The Kubota BX18 subcompact diesel would take most of three hours to mow it on WOT. The Kubota zero turn would do it in 45 minutes and would cut cleaner.
|
|
Check out the thread I started a few days ago asking a similar question. I've received a lot of good info.
http://www.ar15.com/forums/t_1_5/2023924_New-yard-Need-new-mower-.html |
|
|
|
|
Kubota F series with their 100inch deck. Only about 40k nothing for people on this site oh.
I use a BX23s and offset pull behind for 100inch cut works well for me. |
|
Zero Turn. Our lawn used to take 3 to 4 hours to mow. Zero Turn has that down to 45 minutes.
|
|
|
ZTR, but not a home center model - you need the acreage machine.
I bought my Toro ZX online, free freight, arrived on a pallet, some assembly required. But saved about a grand. At that time Home Depot was selling the Toro Z model - but not the ZX, the ZX was virtually a commercial quality machine. The Z model was home owner quality. They look similar, but are quite different in quality. By the way, I ended up giving my son our Garden tractor, since once I got the ZTR it just sat. Remember a Garden tractor isn't a mower, but it does cut grass among other things. |
|
Get the biggest deck u can get. Then get the next size up.
Mowing sucks..... |
|
View Quote And cut their grass for them. |
|
Quoted:
ZTR, but not a home center model - you need the acreage machine. I bought my Toro ZX online, free freight, arrived on a pallet, some assembly required. But saved about a grand. At that time Home Depot was selling the Toro Z model - but not the ZX, the ZX was virtually a commercial quality machine. The Z model was home owner quality. They look similar, but are quite different in quality. By the way, I ended up giving my son our Garden tractor, since once I got the ZTR it just sat. Remember a Garden tractor isn't a mower, but it does cut grass among other things. View Quote |
|
I mow 3 acres with a Dixie Chopper and it takes about 1.5-1.75 hours. Lots of trees and a steep ditch bank on one edge. I guesstimate that it would take me close to an hour more on a lawn tractor. I'll also say that if your yard has any steep grades, ZTR's might not be the best for you.
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
ZTR, but not a home center model - you need the acreage machine. I bought my Toro ZX online, free freight, arrived on a pallet, some assembly required. But saved about a grand. At that time Home Depot was selling the Toro Z model - but not the ZX, the ZX was virtually a commercial quality machine. The Z model was home owner quality. They look similar, but are quite different in quality. By the way, I ended up giving my son our Garden tractor, since once I got the ZTR it just sat. Remember a Garden tractor isn't a mower, but it does cut grass among other things. |
|
Zero turn and not a John Deere . Don't believe the crap about the dealers being better than the box stores. Mine was improperly assembled by the dealer and I ended up fixing it myself as they could not figure out what was wrong.
|
|
I am betting on commercial zero turn, as I don't think underslung mowers are common on small (not garden) tractors anymore. Second vote is for goats.
i have a zero turn, it really sucks when the ground gets rough. I assume commercial models have suspension |
|
PeteyPete, I posted this in the other thread, but it is a great article to review before you choose....
Best ZTR's - How to choose |
|
Hey, also I saved on sales tax too when I bought my Toro ZX online from Speedway Sales in Wisconsin.
But I'm not sure they're in business doing this anymore, I called the number and got their voicemail system but no one was available to take a call, I left a message that their website was down in case they didn't know and are still in business. But, between a great price, free shipping, and no sales tax - I would deal with them again If I needed a machine and they were still in business. |
|
My acre takes me about 3 hours per week on my Home Depot Cub tractor. That is if everything functions properly. I bought the mower new when we bought the house about 8 years back. The piece of crap has nickel and dimed me to death and driven me nuts. 3 years ago I was out of town on business and the wife blew the engine. We were struggling financially, so her dad decided to be nice and spent 700 bucks on a new Briggs and Stratton and installed it. The problem is, the deck is beat to crap, it doesn't mow evenly and spending 700 bucks to fix a $1500 mower that is already falling apart is just silly. And now I'm stuck driving this thing into the ground to avoid seeming ungrateful.
Anyway, go to a commercial dealer and get as much zero turn as you can afford and make sure to maintain it. |
|
I mow about 2 acres. With regular rider I could mow it in 3.5 hours, I have lots of trees. Got a zero turn had a bigger deck but I can while through it in little under 2 hours.
|
|
ZTR is like flying a ground helicopter. But like a helicopter it needs to be of a high grade and maintainable.
You just can't get these better quality machines at Home Depot or Lowes. Either buy online and do the final setup or pay a local dealer. Used is an option too. I bought a used Grasshopper that lasted me several years before giving it away. The maintenance just got too high, but that mother fucker would take small trees down - it was a freaking tank. |
|
Quoted:
Zero turn and not a John Deere . Don't believe the crap about the dealers being better than the box stores. Mine was improperly assembled by the dealer and I ended up fixing it myself as they could not figure out what was wrong. View Quote |
|
I mow about 2 acres with a 50 in. Cub Cadet Tractor.
Awful damn hard to have a cool beverage in your hand with a zero turn. |
|
Quoted:
I mowed 6 acres that had a lot of trees to go around (15 - 20) and it took 45 minutes with my 50" cut 20HP Dixie Chopper, that time included checking oil and topping off the gasoline. Or you could spend 4 hours + with a "lawn tractor" View Quote |
|
Zero turn 100%
Yes, commercial is obviously better, but not a necessity. They make residential ones for a reason. If your property is smooth, not rocky, and generally easy on mowers, you will be just fine with a good quality twin hydro residential ZTR. |
|
I mow 2 acres with a 60" zero turn. I opted for a Cub Cadet with a steering wheel that is directly tied to the front castors vs. a traditional skid steer design since I have some slope on my yard and I can more effectively counter steer into the slope with the wheel. It also is a bit easier when towing small yard implements, like a fertilizer spreader, sprayer, aerator, roller, wagon, etc.
It isn't rated to tow or haul a lot, but does all the basic yard patience things I need. Two things to think about. 1) Bigger deck = less mowing time of course, but also makes getting around tighter spaces for trimming a little harder at times. 2) If your deck is significantly wider than the wheel track width, be sure you are ok not mowing "wheel to wheel" like you might with a push mower. The first few times I mowed I found myself subconsciously lining up on the last rows wheel line and realized I wasn't fully utilizing about 12" of available mower deck width that way. When I had a smaller yard and push-mowed I needed to more or less go in the previous wheel mark to get good overlap and not leave a little row of grass sticking up. |
|
I mow 4.5 acres with a JD Z425 , 54 inch deck bought it new in 2013
have 320 hrs on it now with zero problems , TS2 |
|
John Deere X300 does fine for me. Zero turn would probably save you some time though.
|
|
Dealer nearby that sells Gravely, Scag, Ferris, Grass Hopper, Dixie Chopper, Hustler, Bad Boy. At a minimum with 2800 series hydros, but 3100 series minimum would be better . I like the Kawasaki engine options. Most of the manufacturer I listed use the same bank for 0% if you need it.
|
|
Quoted:
I mow about 2 acres with a 50 in. Cub Cadet Tractor. Awful damn hard to have a cool beverage in your hand with a zero turn. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Not mine !! I have a 60" Country Clipper Edge XLT and is a single joystick. 24 hp Kawasaki, pivoting front axle and a manufactured deck with excellent bullnose and anti-scalp rollers. Does a great job on my hilly, rough-ass 5.5 acres. I will change rear tires to some atv type knobbies when these turfs wear down a little more for better traction on the hills and when a little wet with dew. Stand up deck too for cleaning, blade service. $5300 3 years ago. View Quote |
|
We have almost 2.5 acres as well. I had been using a 90's MTD riding mower and I'd kept it going all these years, but there were so many things breaking down on it at once this year and it was taking 4-6 hours (or more at the end) to do the lawn so we decided to bite the bullet too.
We decided on Husqvarna in the $2000 range. We found the max deck width we could get at stores for that price was about 48-50". Then we found mowersdirect.com and got up to 54" for the same price (it was on sale at the time for just under $2K). We went for it and I love it! Here's the link to what we got: https://www.mowersdirect.com/Husqvarna-960-43-01-88-Lawn-Mower/p12257.html Even though it's not a zero turn, I'm amazed at the turn radius it's capable of. I can still turn tight corners around trees and now we can get the whole yard done in 2 hours. I'm still geeking out on it coming from a much less powerful and much wider turn piece of machinery my older mower was. |
|
Garden tractor with a belly motor w/ a FEL. You'll use that FEL for everything.
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.